FTL Collisions in Star Wars: Fact or Fiction?

Thread starter TheQuietOne
Start date Apr 17, 2016
Tags

Lightspeed Mystery Star Star wars

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the hypothetical scenario of two Star Destroyers colliding at faster-than-light (FTL) speeds in the Star Wars universe. Participants explore the implications of such a collision, considering the fictional nature of hyperspace and the potential effects on the ships and their occupants.

Discussion Character

Exploratory
Debate/contested
Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

Some participants wonder if two Star Destroyers could collide during lightspeed without causing damage, suggesting the possibility of existing in different states of matter.
Others argue that since hyperspace is a fictional construct, the rules governing it are not defined, leading to uncertainty about the outcomes of such collisions.
One participant proposes that if the ships were in their own "private hyperspace," they might avoid collision altogether.
Concerns are raised about the implications of a collision on the occupants of the ships, with some suggesting humorous or absurd outcomes.
Several participants note that while it is fun to speculate, there is no definitive answer to what would happen, as the scenario is purely fictional.
A reference is made to a similar scenario in another sci-fi series, indicating that such collisions have been depicted differently in various contexts.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that the scenario is speculative and lacks definitive answers, with multiple competing views on the implications of FTL collisions remaining unresolved.

Contextual Notes

The discussion is limited by the fictional nature of the Star Wars universe and the undefined rules of hyperspace travel, which prevent any conclusive statements about the physics involved.

Who May Find This Useful

Fans of science fiction, particularly those interested in the Star Wars universe, as well as writers and creators exploring speculative scenarios in their narratives.

Jun 23, 2016

Drakkith

Mentor

phinds said:

They are of course what is called vacuously true

Phinds, what did we tell you about using big words?

phinds said:

1) If matter can travel FTL then a collision would produce long blue tentacles on the creatures.
2) If matter can travel FTL then a collision would produce <insert statement of your choice>

I like option one. Though option two looks promising.