Gauss' Law: Solid Non-conducting Cylinder

[Bryon]

Homework Statement

A long, solid, non-conducting cylinder of radius 8 cm has a non-uniform volume density, ρ, that is a function of the radial distance r from the axis of the cylinder. ρ = A*r2 where A is a constant of value 2.9 μC/m5.

What is the magnitude of the electric field 7 cm from the axis of the cylinder?

Homework Equations

Volume of a cylinder: pi*L*R^2
Gauss' Law: ∫ E·dA = E(pi*L*R^2) = Q_inside*ε₀

The Attempt at a Solution

ρ = A*r2 = (2.9x10^-6)*0.7^3 = 1.421e-8

ρV = (1.421x10^-8)* pi*0.7^2 = 2.18745955e-10

E = (Q_inside*pi*r^2)/ε₀ = 5.433109096 N/C

That does not look right at all to me, and I am not sure where my set up went wrong. Its obvious to me that I did not need the length of the cylinder so I ommited L (actually assumed a value of 1). Did I get the volume correct?

 

[Metaleer]

Hi, Bryon.

First of all, we have Gauss' law:

\oint_\mathcal{S} \mathbf{E} \cdot d\mathbf{S} = \frac{Q_\text{int}}{\epsilon_0}​

The point where they ask you to get the E field is inside the cylinder, so to get this E field, you would need to set up a gaussian cylinder of radius 7 cm (I'd work symbolically until the very end) and use Gauss' law. The evaluation of the LHS is very easy, it is merely the E times the curved outer surface area of the gaussian cylinder (the sides don't add to the flux integral because there, E is perpendicular to the surface). Assuming that the cylinder is of radius r and length L, this turns out to be E 2 \pi r L.

The RHS is slightly trickier, as this involves the total charge contained in the gaussian cylinder. That is:

Q_\text{int} = \int_V \rho dv​

To work out the differential element of volume, we remember that the volume of a cylinder is v = \pi r^2 L, and differentiating with respect to r, we have dv = 2 \pi r L dr. We also have the charge density \rho as a function of r. Plugging it into the charge equation,

Q_\text{int} = \int_V \rho dv = \int_0^r A r'^2 2 \pi r' L dr' = \frac{A \pi L r^4}{2}​

where I added ' to the integrand to not confuse it with the upper limit. All you need to do now is set both sides of Gauss' law equal to each other, solve for the E field, and not forgetting to do unit conversion, evaluate it at r = 7 cm.

Notice how when you set them equal, the L's cancel out, as expected - this is a better method than to assume it's value to be 1. 1 What? cm? m?

Good luck.

 

[Bryon]

Ah I see. I was not sure how to get rid of L. Which I just assumed to be 1m.

 

[Bryon]

Ah now that I read your post I makes a lot more sense! Thanks!