Group of p-power order isomorphism

G doesn't have an element of order p2, then Z/p2 is a subgroup of G, and Z/p × Z/p is isomorphic to G. if G does have an element of order p2, then Z/p2 is not a subgroup of G, and Z/p × Z/p is not isomorphic to G.f
  • #1
81
0

Homework Statement


Let G be a group of order p2, where p is a positive prime.

Show that G is isomorphic to either Z/p2 or Z/p × Z/p.



The Attempt at a Solution



Am I completely wrong here or is this just the definition of a p-Sylow subgroup? what I mean is that if g is of order p2 then there is a subgroup of order p and of order p2, which are isomorphic to Zp and Zp2 (respectively).
Also, if the Sylow group is isomorphic to Zp, it is abelian, would that consequently make G abelian? Not too sure how to put all this into mathematical form...
 
  • #2
Well, by definition G is a p-group and the only non-trivial Sylow p-subgroup of a p-group is the whole group itself.

There is clearly a subgroup of order [itex] p^2 [/itex] (G itself), but a priori there is no reason to assume it's cyclic. I assume you're using Cauchy's theorem to say there is a subgroup of order p, and certainly it must be cyclic. You could use this to argue that the group is isomorphic to [itex] \mathbb Z/p \times \mathbb Z/p [/itex] but there is an easier way.

Do you know about the class equation? Can you show that the center of a p-group is always non-trivial?
 
  • #3

Homework Statement


Let G be a group of order p2, where p is a positive prime.

Show that G is isomorphic to either Z/p2 or Z/p × Z/p.



The Attempt at a Solution



Am I completely wrong here or is this just the definition of a p-Sylow subgroup? what I mean is that if g is of order p2 then there is a subgroup of order p and of order p2, which are isomorphic to Zp and Zp2 (respectively).
Also, if the Sylow group is isomorphic to Zp, it is abelian, would that consequently make G abelian? Not too sure how to put all this into mathematical form...

since G is a p-group, it IS it's own p-Sylow subgroup. so the sylow theorems won't help you here.

try this: either G has an element of order p2, or it doesn't, so...
 

Suggested for: Group of p-power order isomorphism

Replies
2
Views
365
Replies
6
Views
644
Replies
4
Views
723
Replies
1
Views
901
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
17
Views
850
Replies
2
Views
603
Replies
6
Views
813
Back
Top