ram1024 said:
this is the argument that shut you down, Tom.
No, it isn't. First of all, I didn't delete this argument. I deleted the argument about monkeys and bamboo (that was a real stroke of genius). Second, I already answered this argument. And third, this argument is so idiotic, there is no way it could shut anybody down.
I've already said it several times, but here I go again: All you are doing here is the following:
1. Assume that Galilean relativity is correct.
2. Assume that measurements taken will agree with Galilean relativity.
3. Assume that any measurements that don't agree with it are wrong.
4. Conclude that Galilean relativity is correct based on 1-3.
You are the very definition of irrationality, as you make no reference to the real world. The data that you tell me to look at will back up SR, which is what you won't accept. Too bad for you.
although it will just get deleted again anyways...
I'll leave it here, but be assured that the next time you post this same drivel, it will be deleted. Do it once, and it's an honest error. Do it twice, and it's annoying. Do it three times, and it's spam.
edit: By the way, your monkey and bamboo argument has been reposted in the thread in the Feedback Forum, so everyone can see how brilliant you are.
