Have You Ever Seen a Movie About Engineers?

  • Thread starter Thread starter kant
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Movie
AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights the underrepresentation of engineers in films, contrasting their portrayal with that of scientists and other professionals. Participants express a desire for more positive depictions of engineers, noting that most films feature them only as background characters. While some acknowledge movies like "Apollo 13" and "October Sky" for including engineering elements, others criticize films like "Hackers" for oversimplifying the subject. There is a concern about the low percentage of engineering degrees awarded in the U.S., which is seen as a national security issue, especially when compared to the high number of engineers graduating in countries like China and India. The conversation emphasizes the need for engaging and accurate storytelling in movies to inspire interest in engineering careers among youth.
kant
Messages
388
Reaction score
0
I saw movies with mathematicians, physicists, biologists... but i never saw a movie depicting engineers.This movie actually actually tries to show engineers in a positive light. I can t remember the last time there was a movie like this. Most often, engineers are depicted in the backgroud.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It's funny how everyone thinks of scientists as negative people and that we need to make "positive" movies to improve that.

Remember, we know the cure for cancer and we are not telling anyone because we are greedy and want the money from selling medical drugs. :rolleyes:
 
I really think we should get more of the limelight.

There have been a lot of movies that touch on the engineering side, but, like you said, it's more to set up the main plot. I think Apollo 13 did a pretty good job including engineers in the story.
 
There are too few engineers in this country. Only 5% of the degrees awarded at an american universities has soemthing to do with engineering. It is no joke. It is a matter of national security to get kids interested in the field.
 
seen it. lame movie. engineering stuff in it doesn't really help out to bring it out of its lame state. my beef? no creativity, characters are poorly developed, the plot goes into superposition and don't even try to connect the dots and see where the writer is going next, as that will require you to have a bipolar mind in order to understand him.

and btw the movie that came closest to any 'engineering' stuff was Hackers, still is the most techy to date next with Takedown
 
Last edited:
kant said:
There are too few engineers in this country. Only 5% of the degrees awarded at an american universities has soemthing to do with engineering. It is no joke. It is a matter of national security to get kids interested in the field.
There was a recent article done in a design magazine I get regarding the rate that China is graduating engineers versus the US. It is wicked scary to think of. I can post a link if you're interested.
 
cronxeh said:
and btw the movie that came closest to any 'engineering' stuff was Hackers, still is the most techy to date.
Hackers? Are you kidding? That movie completely dumbed things down and threw in useless computer graphics so the average joe could feel like it was a techie movie. Horrible trash.

Movies like October Sky are really what need to be put out there. I would like to see a big dollar production done properly though. A big budget movie that takes the time to do it right both technically and story wise.
 
FredGarvin said:
There was a recent article done in a design magazine I get regarding the rate that China is graduating engineers versus the US. It is wicked scary to think of. I can post a link if you're interested.


I already know. I recalled there was an article about China producing a million engineers per year, and India didn t fall too far behind.
 
kant said:
I already know. I recalled there was an article about China producing a million engineers per year, and India didn t fall too far behind.

Well, these engineers don't have much of a choice don't they.
 
  • #10
You may not be too far off on that Jason. However, they probably aren't complaining if they are getting placed into an engineering profession since, I would think, it is a good leg up in income for most in both China and India.
 
Back
Top