- #1
Jagella
- 51
- 0
Hello, friends:
I just got done studying a chapter in a physics text that explains how heat transfers from higher-temperature objects to lower-temperature objects. Unfortunately, that chapter said little about why heat transfers from higher-temperature objects to lower-temperature objects, so naturally I set out to answer that question.
On the macro level, a hotter object in contact with a cooler object will cool while the cooler object will warm up. After some time, the two objects will be the same temperature, and heat exchange will cease. I decided to consider what might be happening at the molecular level. Realizing that the energy levels of molecules vary directly with temperature, I concluded that the molecules in the hotter object must have higher energy levels than the molecules in the cooler object. How might energy be transferred between molecules?
To answer this question, I decided to focus on the simplest system I can think of: two molecules of different energy levels. If a molecule of higher energy, like the molecule of a hot object, comes into contact with a lower-energy molecule like that in a cooler object, then energy is evidently exchanged between the two molecules. Since the hot molecule's energy is the greater of the two, its energy “overcomes” the energy of the cooler molecule, but only to an extant. The energy of the cool molecule “resists” the hot molecule's energy which lessens the energy of the hot molecule. The hot molecule's energy, on the other hand, increases the energy of the cooler molecule. The net effect is that the two molecules acquire an amount of energy that is about equal.
If we zoom out back to the macro level, the trillions of molecules in the two objects are undergoing the kind of process I just described for two molecules. Thermal energy moves from trillions of hot molecule to trillions of cooler molecules. We experience this movement of energy as heat transfer or an increase in temperature in the hotter object and a decrease in energy and in temperature in the cooler object. Once the molecules' energy levels are about the same, heat transfer stops.
A mechanical analogy may help to clarify the process of heat transfer on the molecular level. Say a car moving at 50 miles per hour is rear-ended by a truck moving at 60 miles per hour. If neither vehicle is damaged to the extent that they would slow down from friction, then the car would speed up while the truck might slow down a bit. Some of the truck's kinetic energy is transferred to the car increasing the car's energy while the truck's energy decreases by that same amount of energy. More energy for the car increases its speed; less energy for the truck decreases its speed. Molecules exchange energy in a similar fashion.
Am I right or wrong about what accounts for heat transfer? At this point you may agree or disagree with what I'm saying. Whether I'm right or wrong is not terribly important to the point I'm trying to make. I'm trying to demonstrate basic reasoning that should be useful in answering scientific questions.
I'd appreciate some feedback on this issue.
Jagella
I just got done studying a chapter in a physics text that explains how heat transfers from higher-temperature objects to lower-temperature objects. Unfortunately, that chapter said little about why heat transfers from higher-temperature objects to lower-temperature objects, so naturally I set out to answer that question.
On the macro level, a hotter object in contact with a cooler object will cool while the cooler object will warm up. After some time, the two objects will be the same temperature, and heat exchange will cease. I decided to consider what might be happening at the molecular level. Realizing that the energy levels of molecules vary directly with temperature, I concluded that the molecules in the hotter object must have higher energy levels than the molecules in the cooler object. How might energy be transferred between molecules?
To answer this question, I decided to focus on the simplest system I can think of: two molecules of different energy levels. If a molecule of higher energy, like the molecule of a hot object, comes into contact with a lower-energy molecule like that in a cooler object, then energy is evidently exchanged between the two molecules. Since the hot molecule's energy is the greater of the two, its energy “overcomes” the energy of the cooler molecule, but only to an extant. The energy of the cool molecule “resists” the hot molecule's energy which lessens the energy of the hot molecule. The hot molecule's energy, on the other hand, increases the energy of the cooler molecule. The net effect is that the two molecules acquire an amount of energy that is about equal.
If we zoom out back to the macro level, the trillions of molecules in the two objects are undergoing the kind of process I just described for two molecules. Thermal energy moves from trillions of hot molecule to trillions of cooler molecules. We experience this movement of energy as heat transfer or an increase in temperature in the hotter object and a decrease in energy and in temperature in the cooler object. Once the molecules' energy levels are about the same, heat transfer stops.
A mechanical analogy may help to clarify the process of heat transfer on the molecular level. Say a car moving at 50 miles per hour is rear-ended by a truck moving at 60 miles per hour. If neither vehicle is damaged to the extent that they would slow down from friction, then the car would speed up while the truck might slow down a bit. Some of the truck's kinetic energy is transferred to the car increasing the car's energy while the truck's energy decreases by that same amount of energy. More energy for the car increases its speed; less energy for the truck decreases its speed. Molecules exchange energy in a similar fashion.
Am I right or wrong about what accounts for heat transfer? At this point you may agree or disagree with what I'm saying. Whether I'm right or wrong is not terribly important to the point I'm trying to make. I'm trying to demonstrate basic reasoning that should be useful in answering scientific questions.
I'd appreciate some feedback on this issue.
Jagella