Helicopter hovering in crosswind with tail rotor

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the dynamics of a helicopter hovering in a steady crosswind, focusing on the conditions under which the effectiveness of the tail rotor may be reduced or lost. Participants explore the torque relationships between the main and tail rotors, the implications of induced power factors, and the effects of crosswind on helicopter stability and control.

Discussion Character

  • Homework-related
  • Technical explanation
  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants propose that the torque of the tail rotor must counteract the torque created by the main rotor, leading to the need for torque equations for both rotors.
  • There is uncertainty regarding the meaning of the induced power factor of 1.15 at the tail rotor and its implications for calculations.
  • Participants question how to derive the tail rotor thrust and induced velocity without sufficient information about the tail rotor's area or disk loading.
  • Some suggest that the tail rotor's effectiveness may be compromised in certain crosswind scenarios, while others explore the dynamics of flying sideways as a related concept.
  • There is a discussion about the relationship between thrust, weight, and induced vortices, particularly in hover versus forward flight.
  • One participant mentions that the tail rotor typically operates at a fixed multiple of the main rotor speed, which may influence its torque output.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the implications of crosswinds for tail rotor effectiveness and the calculations necessary to analyze the situation. There is no consensus on the specific conditions that lead to reduced effectiveness or the interpretation of the induced power factor.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include missing information about the main rotor size and tail rotor area, as well as unresolved mathematical steps related to thrust and induced velocity calculations.

Hey_Ducky
Messages
1
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A helicopter is hovering in a steady cross wind at a gross weight of 3,000lb. The helicopter has 275 hp delivered to the main rotor shaft. The tail rotor radius is 2.3 ft and has an induced power factor of 1.15. The tail rotor is located 15.3 ft away from the main rotor shaft. Determine the crosswind conditions (velocity and direction) in which tail rotor effectiveness may be reduced or lost. If the center of gravity is assumed to lie on the rotor shaft axis, determine the feasible yawing angular velocity that the pilot can demand that may also result in a loss of tail rotor effectiveness

Homework Equations


My understanding is that the torque of the tail rotor needs to counteract, ie, be equal to the torque created by the main rotor. For that reason, my first goal is to right down torque equation for each scenario. Leishman, my textbook, uses Q = Torque, T = Thrust (here, same as weight in hover).

Qrotor = T * Vinduced/(Vtip/R)
Qtail = r x f = |r| |f| sin(theta)
--> Figure out under what circumstances Qtail < Qrotor

I'm interested in exploring the angle of the crosswind, so theta is fine.
Known (or solvable): T, R, Vi, r
Vi = sqrt(T/ (2*A*rho))
Unknown: Vtip (how do I deal with this?)
Not sure: f ? and theta

F must be the thrust exerted by the tail rotor. So, call it Ttail ?
In rotorcraft P = T * Vi.
Here's where I'm stuck. How do I use the induced power factor to get Ptail? How do I get Vi,tail? I don't have area or disk loading or really any information about the tail?

Am I on the right track? Your help would be greatly appreciated.

The Attempt at a Solution

 
Physics news on Phys.org
There seems to be insufficient information. It's not clear to me what an induced power factor of 1.15 at the tail rotor means. The main rotor size is not stated either. Also it takes less power to hover in a crosswind versus zero wind, but I don't know if your textbook explains this.
 
Last edited:
Hey_Ducky said:

Homework Statement


A helicopter is hovering in a steady cross wind at a gross weight mass* of 3,000lb.
My understanding is that the torque of the tail rotor needs to counteract, ie, be equal to the torque created by the main rotor. For that reason, my first goal is to right down torque equation for each scenario. Leishman, my textbook, uses Q = Torque, T = Thrust (here, same as weight in hover).

I don't have area or disk loading or really any information about the tail?

Right, so in what situation (can you think of) would the torque caused by the tail rotor be lower compared to the torque of the main rotor?

You do have a radius, could you not find the area using that?

Also, remember that since the helicopter is in hover, the downward thrust is equal to the weight.

Weight = mass * gravity
 
Last edited:
theOrange said:
Right, so in what situation (can you think of) would the torque caused by the tail rotor be lower compared to the torque of the main rotor?
Typically, the tail rotor moves at some fixed multiple of the speed of the main rotor, and the pitch of the blades on the tail rotor is changed to vary the amount of torque on the tail rotor. Instead of a cross wind situation, imagine flying a helicopter sideways; I'm not sure of the limits for flying full scale helicopters sideways, but aerobatic radio control model helicopters can be flown at top speed sideways, with the top speed is reduced due to the drag of the fuselage being flown sideways. The limitaion on sideways speed is due to the main rotor, not the tail rotor which is essentially a variable pitch propeller.

theOrange said:
Also, remember that since the helicopter is in hover, the downward thrust is equal to the weight.
And for some given period of time Δt, the impulse (thrust x Δt ) equals the change in momentum of the air. Assuming some fixed amount of mass of air flowing per unit time mdot, then change in momentum = mdot Δv. The change in momentum must deal with the induced vortice flow, which is greater when hovering compared to forward or sideways flight at sufficient speed. Links:

http://www.copters.com/aero/hovering.html

http://www.copters.com/aero/translational.html
 
Last edited:
rcgldr said:
Typically, the tail rotor moves at some fixed multiple of the speed of the main rotor, and the pitch of the blades on the tail rotor is changed to vary the amount of torque on the tail rotor. Instead of a cross wind situation, imagine flying a helicopter sideways; I'm not sure of the limits for flying full scale helicopters sideways, but aerobatic radio control model helicopters can be flown at top speed sideways, with the top speed is reduced due to the drag of the fuselage being flown sideways. The limitaion on sideways speed is due to the main rotor, not the tail rotor which is essentially a variable pitch propeller.

An for some given period of time Δt, the impulse (thrust x Δt ) equals the change in momentum of the air. Assuming some fixed amount of mass of air flowing per unit time mdot, then change in momentum = mdot Δv. The change in momentum must deal with the induced vortice flow, which is greater when hovering compared to forward or sideways flight at sufficient speed. Links:

http://www.copters.com/aero/hovering.html

http://www.copters.com/aero/translational.html

I know, I'm giving the OP some questions to think about.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
10K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
13K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
5K