Help Not sure what im doing wrong

  • Thread starter Thread starter BunDa4Th
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves a bullet impacting a wooden block, with the goal of determining the bullet's speed before impact. The scenario includes concepts from mechanics, specifically momentum conservation and frictional forces affecting motion.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss calculating the block's speed after the bullet impacts it and question the use of time in their calculations. There are attempts to relate the forces acting on the block to its motion and to clarify the variables involved in the equations.

Discussion Status

Multiple interpretations of the equations and variables are being explored. Some participants express confusion about the relationships between mass, velocity, and acceleration, while others provide insights into using Newton's laws and kinematic equations. Guidance has been offered on how to approach the problem using conservation of momentum and kinematic relationships.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention a lack of prior instruction on relevant topics, which may contribute to their uncertainty in applying the concepts correctly. There is also a recognition of the complexity introduced by friction in the problem setup.

BunDa4Th
Messages
188
Reaction score
0
Help! Not sure what I am doing wrong

A 11.4 g bullet is fired horizontally into a 94 g wooden block initially at rest on a horizontal surface. After impact, the block slides 7.5 m before coming to rest. If the coefficient of kinetic friction between block and surface is 0.650, what was the speed of the bullet immediately before impact? m/s

first thing i did was find the block speed

t = sqrt((7.5)(.65)/9.8)

t = .7053

then i did

V = deltax/t = 7.5/.7053 = 10.6338

mv_1 + Mv_2 = (m + M)V

V = 98.31 which is incorrect but answer is within 10% of the correct value.

I am not sure if I am doing this correctly or I am just completely off.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
BunDa4Th said:
A 11.4 g bullet is fired horizontally into a 94 g wooden block initially at rest on a horizontal surface. After impact, the block slides 7.5 m before coming to rest. If the coefficient of kinetic friction between block and surface is 0.650, what was the speed of the bullet immediately before impact? m/s

first thing i did was find the block speed

t = sqrt((7.5)(.65)/9.8)

t = .7053

then i did

V = deltax/t = 7.5/.7053 = 10.6338

mv_1 + Mv_2 = (m + M)V

V = 98.31 which is incorrect but answer is within 10% of the correct value.

I am not sure if I am doing this correctly or I am just completely off.
Your V is on the order of 10% too high. It should be less than 10m/s

t = sqrt(mu*s/g)?

I assume that last V means v_1
 
Last edited:
V is the velocity of the moving block.

Also i thought to get "t" it is t = sqrt(deltaX/g) but i was not sure how to get it on here since friction play a part of this problem.

t = sqrt(mu*s/g) what is "s"? i know that mu is the kinetic friction and g is gravity but what is s?
 
BunDa4Th said:
V is the velocity of the moving block.
That is not what it is here
BunDa4Th said:
V = 98.31 which is incorrect but answer is within 10% of the correct value.
Also i thought to get "t" it is t = sqrt(deltaX/g) but i was not sure how to get it on here since friction play a part of this problem.

t = sqrt(mu*s/g) what is "s"? i know that mu is the kinetic friction and g is gravity but what is s?
s is often used for distance. You called it deltaX here. So change my query to

t = sqrt(mu*deltaX/g)? There is no such equation.

From V_f - V = a*t you get V = -a*t (zero final velocity)
V is the initial velocity of the block after collision, as you defined it. The acceleration is negative (decleration). So

t = -V/a

apply Newton's second law to find a

(M+m)a = F_f = force of friction = mu*N = mu*(M+m)g

etc

Alternatively, once you identify a from the above, instead of finding the time you can use the equation that relates the change of velocity squared to acceleration and distance moved.
 
okay you just completely lost me there.

but i seem to got the answer somehow by doing this way which is probably incorrect to do it and i just got lucky and got it correct (this is what i got from reading what you posted). I am trying to figure out what you are telling me but i can't seem to understand it. sorry if I am giving you a much harder time on this, but my professor never went over this (she skip more than half of the chapter) and expect us to know it.

m_bulletv_i = (m + M)g

11.4v_i = (11.4 + 94)(9.8)

11.4v_i = 1032.92
v_i = 90.61 m/s
 
BunDa4Th said:
okay you just completely lost me there.

but i seem to got the answer somehow by doing this way which is probably incorrect to do it and i just got lucky and got it correct (this is what i got from reading what you posted). I am trying to figure out what you are telling me but i can't seem to understand it. sorry if I am giving you a much harder time on this, but my professor never went over this (she skip more than half of the chapter) and expect us to know it.

m_bulletv_i = (m + M)g

11.4v_i = (11.4 + 94)(9.8)

11.4v_i = 1032.92
v_i = 90.61 m/s
Momentum is conserved at impact, but why do you say m_bulletv_i = (m +M)g? where does the g come from??
 
BunDa4Th said:
m_bulletv_i = (m + M)g
Mass time velocity cannot possibly equal mass times acceleration.
You had this correct earlier
mv_1 + Mv_2 = (m + M)V
Just recognize that v_2= 0

Solve the equation I started for you relating (M+m)a to mu*(M+m)*g to find a. Find the value of V from the known stopping distance and the acceleration. Then use V in the equation above to find v_1
 
(94 + 11.4)a = .65(94 + 11.4) (9.8)
105.4a = 671.398
a = 6.37 is this correct?
 
BunDa4Th said:
(94 + 11.4)a = .65(94 + 11.4) (9.8)
105.4a = 671.398
a = 6.37 is this correct?
Yes, now proceed per Dan's earlier responses.
 
  • #10
that is where i am stuck how would i go from there if t = -V/a

which is t = -V/6.37
 
  • #11
BunDa4Th said:
that is where i am stuck how would i go from there if t = -V/a

which is t = -V/6.37
It's best now that you know what a is, to use v^2 = 2as, wher s = 7.5 meters. and a = 6.37m/s/s. This is the initial velocity of the block/bullet system after impact. Then use conservation of momentum to solve for v_bullet. Make sure to include units in your answers.
 
  • #12
Thanks a lot it was correct. Thanks for taking the time on explaining and giving a step by step on how to do this. I forgot about the kinetic equation. Both of you were great help on explaining and taking the time to help me solve this.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 38 ·
2
Replies
38
Views
4K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
41
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K