Heroine's Final Fight - Is Penetrating Chest-bone Physically Possible?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DHF
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Final
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on the physical feasibility of a heroine delivering a fatal blow to an arch villain by penetrating the chest area, specifically the sternum or ribs. It is clarified that while breaking ribs or the sternum can occur, particularly during CPR, using a fist to penetrate the chest is highly unlikely due to the strength of the rib cage and surrounding muscles. The only potential method for achieving such a feat with a fist would involve extending fingers to concentrate force, but this would likely result in injury to the attacker. The conversation also touches on the xiphoid process, a small bone at the sternum's base, which could be broken in a fight and potentially lead to fatal consequences, although this scenario may not align with the desired narrative outcome. The conclusion emphasizes the need to adjust the scene or introduce a different mechanism to make the heroine's action plausible.
DHF
Messages
247
Reaction score
32
Hello everyone,

The following is continued research on a book my wife and I are writing. In said book our Heroine has enhanced speed and strength but during the final act of the book she is constrained to the limits of human strength. We have decided that she would be capable of the limits of what is humanly possible but not beyond. This leads to our final fight scene where she is fighting the arch villain. My wife would very much like for the Heroine to deliver the final blow by penetrating the Villain's Chest-bone but I have no idea if this is physically possible.

Can this happen?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
By "chest bone" do you mean the sternum? Or do you mean break through the ribs?
Penetrate using what? With a sword, or other sharp weapon, definitely. With a blunt object, perhaps. With her fists...very unlikely. You might be able to break a rib or two with a strong punch, but there's no way you're tearing through all that pectoral muscle and through the rib cage to make a hole in a person's chest with your fist.

The only way you might be able to get enough pressure is perhaps by extending your fingers to make the area of contact much much smaller. In such a case, I would expect your fingers to break long before you break through the other person's chest.
 
yes she would be using her fist. and thank you for confirmation that it wouldn't work. we can now start to re write the scene to either change what she does or invent a mechanism to make it possible.

I appreciate the information.
 
When people get CPR it's pretty common for the breastbone to break, sometimes a few ribs too. When I had my heart attack a few years ago, it was the cartiledge in the middle of my breast bone. I think. Small price to pay for getting blood to circulate through your brain.
 
What tends to break during CPR (other than the occasional rib) is the small triangular end bone of the sternum, in Swedish known as the "dagger bone". If it dislodges it can cause extensive damage to all the surrounding tissue. This small bone could also be broken off durin your final fight, but this would lead to a prolonged death- perhaps not what you are looking for...
 
You are talking about the xiphoid process. Sure, you can kill someone by hitting this..
 
Man, when the Devil comes a-knockin', he does not smell of sulphur and brimstone, he smells of sweet perfume and roses... Doing a bit of research for a short story. All I wanted was some examples of professions typical for jurors in a trial of the time and location of the story (1850s New Orleans - of which I am not very familiar, so I have my work cut out for me). ChatGPT delivered that very nicely, giving me a list of a dozen typical professions for the type of man that was eligible for...
Back
Top