Hi,I was wondering if acceleration was a form of nonuniform speed?

AI Thread Summary
Acceleration is indeed a form of nonuniform speed, as it involves changes in velocity, which can occur even at constant speed along a curved path. While speed is the magnitude of velocity and directionally independent, acceleration can happen when an object's direction changes, leading to confusion about the relationship between speed and acceleration. The discussion emphasizes that uniform speed can coexist with acceleration, particularly when considering total speed across different directions. It clarifies that changes in direction involve a decrease in speed in one dimension and an increase in another, reinforcing the concept of nonuniform speed. Overall, the conversation highlights the nuanced understanding of speed, velocity, and acceleration in physics.
Bashyboy
Messages
1,419
Reaction score
5
Hi,

I was wondering if acceleration was a form of nonuniform speed?
 
Physics news on Phys.org


That's what it means!
 


Well, thank you very much for answering so promptly.
 


Well...

Acceleration means nonuniform velocity. An object can have a uniform speed and still be accelerating (if it is following a curved path at a constant speed).
 


I said it the wrong way round; non-uniform speed is called / is an example of acceleration.
You are right about change of direction, of course. Mea culpa for being so sloppy.
 


cjl said:
Well...

Acceleration means nonuniform velocity. An object can have a uniform speed and still be accelerating (if it is following a curved path at a constant speed).

Changing your direction is actually just a decrease in speed in one orthogonal dimension and an increase in another however, so fundamentally it is non-uniform speed.
 


LostConjugate said:
Changing your direction is actually just a decrease in speed in one orthogonal dimension and an increase in another however, so fundamentally it is non-uniform speed.

Since speed is the magnitude of velocity, that isn't really the case.
 


cjl said:
Since speed is the magnitude of velocity, that isn't really the case.

Total speed is the magnitude of velocity. Acceleration is non-uniform speed in at least 1 spatial direction.
 


LostConjugate said:
Total speed is the magnitude of velocity. Acceleration is non-uniform speed in at least 1 spatial direction.

You're trying to invoke direction, but by definition, speed is directionally independent. If you include directional information, you're talking about velocity, not speed.
 
  • #10


cjl said:
You're trying to invoke direction, but by definition, speed is directionally independent. If you include directional information, you're talking about velocity, not speed.

I was commenting on your remark that acceleration means nonuniform velocity. And that you can have a uniform speed and still be accelerating. What you mean is that you can have a uniform "total" speed in all directions and still be accelerating. This makes it much more confusing than it actually is and people get confused as to why changing direction is acceleration, it makes it sound mysterious when it is not.

You can't say that your speed is uniform because you are making up for a loss in speed in one orthogonal direction by a gain in speed in another orthogonal direction. This is why they are "orthogonal".

When you go around a turn in your car you are reducing your speed in the direction you were travelling, this is why you feel the same effect as if you press on your brake.
 
  • #11


This is a physics board and we are using the word "speed" in its technical, physics, meaning. Talking about "speed in the direction you were travelling" indicates that you are not.
 
Back
Top