How do I calculate the ratio of forces between two conducting spheres?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the ratio of forces between two conducting spheres after they touch and share charge. Initially, the assumption was that the forces would be equal, leading to an incorrect answer choice. After the spheres touch, they share the total charge equally, resulting in each sphere having a charge of Q/2. The conversation emphasizes the need to analyze the forces before and after the spheres come into contact. Understanding the charge distribution is crucial for determining the resulting force ratios.
samcoelho
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
Two identical conducting spheres are charged to +2Q and -Q, respectively, and are separated by a distance d (much greater than the radii of the spheres) as shown above. The magnitude of the force of attraction on the left sphere is F1. After the two spheres are made to touch and then are reseparated by distance d, the magnitude of the force on the left sphere is F2. Which of the following relationships is correct?
Relevant Equations
Coulomb's Law: F=k|q1q2|/r^2
Here are the answer choices:
a) F1 = 2F2
b) F1 = 8F2
c) 2F1 = F2
d) F1 = 4F2
e) F1 = F2

I figured that Coulomb's law would tell us the magnitude of the forces are identical, so I answered E, but that was incorrect.

(Screenshot of question attached)
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2021-05-03 at 10.07.26 AM.png
    Screen Shot 2021-05-03 at 10.07.26 AM.png
    10.3 KB · Views: 198
Physics news on Phys.org
After the spheres touch, how much charge is on each?
 
If the magnitude of the forces was unequal, we could use this experiment to propel a space vehicle.
 
tech99 said:
If the magnitude of the forces was unequal, we could use this experiment to propel a space vehicle.
You seem to have misread the question.
 
Steve4Physics said:
After the spheres touch, how much charge is on each?
Equal amount, so does each sphere then have 1/2 Q charge?
 
samcoelho said:
Equal amount, so does each sphere then have 1/2 Q charge?
Yes, well done.

The total charge is (2Q) + (-Q) = Q. Since the spheres are identical, this total charge gets split equally, ##\frac Q 2## each.
 
Steve4Physics said:
Yes, well done.

The total charge is (2Q) + (-Q) = Q. Since the spheres are identical, this total charge gets split equally, ##\frac Q 2## each.
samcoelho said:
Equal amount, so does each sphere then have 1/2 Q charge?
Good.
Now finish off. What are the before & after forces?
 
Back
Top