How Does Force Affect Pressure Change in a Cylinder with a Piston?

1 reply · 3K views · last reply
rajumahtora
Messages
18
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Given below is a cylinder with piston with same area at both the ends. The cylinder holds pure water in it. If force F is applied from both the ends, find the change in pressure at point B.Ignore Atmospheric Pressure

2. Diagram

Diagram of a cylinder with a piston at each end, labelled B for the water inside. Equal forces F press inward on both pistons, each with area A.


The Attempt at a Solution


According to me, the answer is 2F/A coz we have to add pressure from both the sides.
∴ The change in pressure at Point P is 2F/A.
But the answer given in the solution is F/A. When I said to check the answer, they told that F/A is correct.
How is it possible? Please Explain.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a cylinder closed by a piston at each end, labelled B for the water inside, with force F pushing inward on both pistons and each piston area labelled A.
    paint.jpg
    11 KB · Views: 560
Imagine that you replace all the fluid (and piston) to the left of location B with a new piston, and imagine that you apply whatever force is necessary on that new piston to prevent the fluid to the right of the new piston from moving. Does the fluid on the right of B know that you have done this? No. So the force exerted by the fluid to the left of B and acting to the fluid to the right of B must be F.