Daveman20
- 21
- 0
Do substances radiate particles? Is it the wind brushing up the surface particles of the substance? Do dense materials usually have less smell?
The discussion centers on the mechanisms of smell at the atomic and molecular level, exploring how different substances emit particles and how their physical properties, such as density, relate to olfactory perception. The conversation touches on theoretical aspects of smell, including evaporation rates and molecular interactions with receptors in the nose.
Participants generally agree on the relationship between density, evaporation rates, and smell, but there is disagreement regarding the role of density in determining smell, with multiple competing views presented.
The discussion includes assumptions about the relationship between density and smell, as well as the complexity of molecular interactions that are not fully resolved.
Daveman20 said:Do substances radiate particles? Is it the wind brushing up the surface particles of the substance? Do dense materials usually have less smell?
Mapes said:All solids and liquids evaporate material constantly, yes, though the amount can vary by many orders of magnitude between a volatile liquid and a dense solid. And your intuition is correct, denser materials generally evaporate vapor at a smaller rate (ice cubes will disappear from your freezer in weeks, but a chunk of iron will stick around for a long, long, time). But the ability of the nose to detect specific molecules is another factor.