How Does the Central Limit Theorem Estimate Error in Area Calculations?

  • Thread starter Thread starter nolita_day
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Area Estimation
nolita_day
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Your help/input is much appreciated! Thanks in advance! :smile:

Object A is in the unit square 0<x<1, 0<y<1. Consider a random point distributed uniformly over the square; let Y=1 if the point lies inside A and Y=0 otherwise. How could A be estimated from a sequence of n individual points unif. distr. on the square?

I got this part just taking Y as ~Bernoulli(p=A). Let Y_{i} = f(X_{i}), then A≈\frac{1}{n}\sum{Y_{i}}

How could the CLT be used to gauge the probable size of the error of the estimate? Denoting the estimate by \hat{A}, if A=0.2, how large should n be so that P(|\hat{A} - A| &lt; .01) ≈ .99?

I can't figure out this one. Am I supposed to take \hat{A} as the random variable or |\hat{A}-A| as the RV? What is the standard deviation of \hat{A} vs. |\hat{A}-A|? My attempt below is only for the first part of the question in the previous paragraph.

Taking \hat{A} as the RV, I started out like this...

E[\dfrac{Y_{1}+...+Y_{n}}{n}]=\hat{A}
Then Var(\hat{A})=Var( E[\dfrac{Y_{1}+...+Y_{n}}{n}] )=\frac{1}{n^{2}}Var( nE[Y_{i}] ) = Var( E[Y_{i}] ) = Var(A) (since Yi ~ Bernoulli(A) = A)

To estimate A based on \hat{A}, pick a small error and a high probability of getting that small error and you could use CLT as follows:

P(|\hat{A} - A| &lt; .01) = .99
P(-.01 &lt; \hat{A} - A &lt; .01) = .99
P(\dfrac{-.01}{σ_{\hat{A}}} &lt; \dfrac{\hat{A} - A}{σ_{\hat{A}}} &lt; \dfrac{.01}{σ_{\hat{A}}}) = .99
P(\dfrac{-.01}{\sqrt{A}} &lt; Z &lt; \dfrac{.01}{\sqrt{A}}) = .99
\Phi(\dfrac{.01}{\sqrt{A}}) - \Phi(\dfrac{-.01}{\sqrt{A}}) = .99
2\Phi(\dfrac{.01}{\sqrt{A}}) - 1) = .99
\dfrac{.01}{\sqrt{A}}= 2.58
A = .000015023?

I'm definitely sure this is wrong... how the heck did I come up with an actual number for A?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
This is a bit hard to follow because you confuse A with A-hat.
\hat{A} = \sum Y_i/n, A = E(\hat{A}).
 
Namaste & G'day Postulate: A strongly-knit team wins on average over a less knit one Fundamentals: - Two teams face off with 4 players each - A polo team consists of players that each have assigned to them a measure of their ability (called a "Handicap" - 10 is highest, -2 lowest) I attempted to measure close-knitness of a team in terms of standard deviation (SD) of handicaps of the players. Failure: It turns out that, more often than, a team with a higher SD wins. In my language, that...
Hi all, I've been a roulette player for more than 10 years (although I took time off here and there) and it's only now that I'm trying to understand the physics of the game. Basically my strategy in roulette is to divide the wheel roughly into two halves (let's call them A and B). My theory is that in roulette there will invariably be variance. In other words, if A comes up 5 times in a row, B will be due to come up soon. However I have been proven wrong many times, and I have seen some...
Back
Top