How to calculate a coefficient of performance (COP)

12 replies · 9K views · last reply
Screwed
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Moved from a technical forum, so homework template missing

Homework Statement



Problem sheet for a mole of an ideal diatomic gas on a three-step reversible cycle: isobaric expansion 1 to 2, isothermic compression 2 to 3, isochoric process 3 to 1. A table gives State 1 with P 101300 Pa, Vm ??? kL/mol, T 243.8 K; State 2 with Vm 0.04, T 487.37 K; State 3 unknown. Parts a) to d) ask for states, heat, work, entropy and COP.


Homework Equations



Two boxed comparison formulas: Carnot's inverse cycle gives COP heating = T_H/(T_H - T_C) and COP cooling = T_C/(T_H - T_C); this cycle gives COP heating = Q_OUTPUT/W_Cycle and COP cooling = Q_INPUT/W_Cycle.
[/B][/B]
Xo10cz5


3. The Attempt at a Solution


Here's my solution attempt:

Spreadsheet table of process values for states 1 to 3 with pressure, volume, temperature and heat columns, above a P-V graph showing a triangular cycle with points (0.02; 101300), (0.02; 202600) and (0.04; 101300).


NOTE: Evolution 2 to 3 is really an isothermic process, but in the diagram shows as an politropic process.

Two boxed COP comparisons: Carnot's inverse cycle heating COP = T_H/(T_H - T_C) = 2.00094141 and cooling COP = T_C/(T_H - T_C) = -1.0009; below, this cycle's heating COP = Q_OUTPUT/W_Cycle = 10.05740322 and cooling COP = Q_INPUT/W_Cycle = -9.057403221, with handwritten-style notes on the right.


4. Further Questions

But it isn't giving me logical values of COP when I compare it with a reverse cycle of Carnot.

Question: How could I calculate the COP and COPmax of this cycle?
Not sure how to arrange heats and work on COPs formula for a triangular cycle like this one.
 
Attachments
  • Problem sheet for a mole of an ideal diatomic gas on a three-step reversible cycle: isobaric expansion 1 to 2, isothermic compression 2 to 3, isochoric process 3 to 1. A table gives State 1 with P 101300 Pa, Vm ??? kL/mol, T 243.8 K; State 2 with Vm 0.04, T 487.37 K; State 3 unknown. Parts a) to d) ask for states, heat, work, entropy and COP.
    T48Cd.jpg
    50.7 KB · Views: 1,966
  • Spreadsheet table of thermodynamic process values for states 1 to 3 and processes 1a2, 2a3 and 3a1, with a pressure against volume graph below showing a triangular cycle between points (0.02; 101300), (0.02; 202600) and (0.04; 101300).
    6FbEH.jpg
    48.4 KB · Views: 715
  • Two boxed COP comparisons: Carnot's inverse cycle heating COP = T_H/(T_H - T_C) = 2.00094141 and cooling COP = T_C/(T_H - T_C) = -1.0009; below, this cycle's heating COP = Q_OUTPUT/W_Cycle = 10.05740322 and cooling COP = Q_INPUT/W_Cycle = -9.057403221, with handwritten-style notes on the right.
    a11xc.jpg
    30.7 KB · Views: 5,750
  • Two boxed comparison formulas: Carnot's inverse cycle gives COP heating = T_H/(T_H - T_C) and COP cooling = T_C/(T_H - T_C); this cycle gives COP heating = Q_OUTPUT/W_Cycle and COP cooling = Q_INPUT/W_Cycle.
    Xo10cz5.jpg
    14.5 KB · Views: 5,066
  • Spreadsheet table of process values for states 1 to 3 with pressure, volume, temperature and heat columns, above a P-V graph showing a triangular cycle with points (0.02; 101300), (0.02; 202600) and (0.04; 101300).
    6fbeh-jpg.jpg
    48.4 KB · Views: 1,704
Last edited:
In this cycle, you are removing heat from one part of the surroundings at a low temperature (7088 J) and discharging heat to another part of the surroundings at a higher (range of) temperature (2809 J + 5063 J = 7871 J). To accomplish this pumping of heat, you are supplying work to the system (782.63 J). So, viewed as a heater, its COP is the heat delivered divided by the work done (7871/783). Viewed as a cooler, its COP is the heat removed divided by the work done (7088/783). So basically, except for the sign on cooler performance, both your results are correct.
 
@Chestermiller Thanks! But ...

Can the COP of my cycle be greater than the COP of an equivalent carnot cycle?
I thought that it should always be smaller, even in reversible cycles.
 
Last edited:
Screwed said:
@Chestermiller Thanks! But ...

Can the COP of my cycle be greater than the COP of an equivalent carnot cycle?
I thought that it should always be smaller, even in reversible cycles.
Can you please define the "equivalent Carnot cycle," given that the temperature is changing in steps 1-2 and in 3-1?
 
Chestermiller said:
Can you please define the "equivalent Carnot cycle," given that the temperature is changing in steps 1-2 and in 3-1?
Well... I guess that would be a reverse carnot cycle that works between the same two temperature sinks (243 k and 487k).
Screenshot of a text page titled Carnot efficiency, giving the heat pump Carnot COP formula COPh,Carnot = Tcond [K] / (Tcond - Tevap) and the real COPh = eta times COPh,Carnot, with the note that system efficiency is usually 50% to 70%.
 
Attachments
  • Screenshot of a text page titled Carnot efficiency, giving the heat pump Carnot COP formula COPh,Carnot = Tcond [K] / (Tcond - Tevap) and the real COPh = eta times COPh,Carnot, with the note that system efficiency is usually 50% to 70%.
    20535390178abc4929c40975a6082452fc5fb13ae229b699a510efcf96f068253a518503.jpg
    42.2 KB · Views: 1,212
Last edited:
Screwed said:
Well... I guess that would be a reverse carnot cycle that works between the same two temperature sinks (243 k and 487k).
View attachment 231938
But this system is not operating between 2 constant temperature sinks at 243 and 487. In step 1-2, the system is being heated along the process path from 243 to 487, so it is being brought into contact with a sequence of constant temperature reservoirs running from the lower temperature to the higher temperature. And, in step 3-1, the system is being cooled along the process path from 487 to 243, so it is being brought into contact with a sequence of constant temperature reservoirs running from the higher temperature to the lower temperature. The only part of the process where a single constant temperature reservoir is being used is step 2-3.
 
So, you are saying that since my cycle has an isothermal process, and for it to be reversible this must be achieved with infinite temperature sources ... then the theoretical COP of a carnot cycle does not have to be greater than the COP of my cycle because it does not really have only 2 sources ...

Sorry, I'm still confused, the carnot cycle does not also have reversible isothermal passes?

I always thought that Efficience and COP from Carnot Cycles where always greater than those of other cycles that were not carnot, reversible or irreversible.

I am very grateful for your answers, but I am a bit harsh with this topic.
 
Screwed said:
So, you are saying that since my cycle has an isothermal process, and for it to be reversible this must be achieved with infinite temperature sources ... then the theoretical COP of a carnot cycle does not have to be greater than the COP of my cycle because it does not really have only 2 sources ...
No. That's not what I'm saying. The isothermal (487) reversible step 2-3 is OK to allow a comparison with a Carnot cycle. But, what I'm saying is that that steps 1-2 and 3-1 of your process, although being reversible, are not isothermal. So there is no one temperature along these paths that you can use to compare directly with an isothermal leg of a Carnot cycle. The most you can say is that some temperature between 243 and 487 might be appropriate for such a comparison, but it is not obvious what the specific temperature should be.
 
For whatever it's worth, I have encountered problems like this before and the expected answer for the Carnot efficiency assumes a cycle the isothermals of which are at the highest and lowest possible temperatures at which the system may find itself.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DrClaude
So, s
Chestermiller said:
No. That's not what I'm saying. The isothermal (487) reversible step 2-3 is OK to allow a comparison with a Carnot cycle. But, what I'm saying is that that steps 1-2 and 3-1 of your process, although being reversible, are not isothermal. So there is no one temperature along these paths that you can use to compare directly with an isothermal leg of a Carnot cycle. The most you can say is that some temperature between 243 and 487 might be appropriate for such a comparison, but it is not obvious what the specific temperature should be.

In short, if I have an isobaric or isochoric process in a cycle, then I can not compare to the COP of a carnot cycle because the sinks are not well defined?
 
kuruman said:
For whatever it's worth, I have encountered problems like this before and the expected answer for the Carnot efficiency assumes a cycle the isothermals of which are at the highest and lowest possible temperatures at which the system may find itself.
Do you have an example of that, that would be cool.
 
Screwed said:
So, s


In short, if I have an isobaric or isochoric process in a cycle, then I can not compare to the COP of a carnot cycle because the sinks are not well defined?
Your reversible process is well defined. I just do see how to compare this to a Carnot cycle on a rational basis.
 
Here's an approach to an equivalent Carnot cycle that might make sense.

The transfer of heat to the hot reservoir(s) is 7871 J, and the transfer of entropy to the hot reservoir(s) is 20.16 J/K. So the equivalent Carnot hot reservoir temperature is 7871/20.16 = 390.43 K.

The transfer of heat from the cold reservoir(s) is 7088.62 J, and the transfer of entropy from the cold reservoir(s) is 20.16. So the equivalent Carnot cold reservoir temperature is 7088.62/20.16 = 351.61 K.

Both these values lie between the extreme temperatures of 243K and 487 K. Anyway, use of these two temperatures in a Carnot cycle along with the known heats give exactly the same values for the COPs that we have already calculated.