How to Solve a Double Contour Integral Using Ostrogradsky Formula?

6 replies · 5K views · last reply
evol_w10lv
Messages
70
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


I have got double contour integral:
Handwritten closed surface integral sign with a double circle over a surface, followed by the integrand x dy dz + z dx dy.

And here is picture:
3D coordinate sketch of a tetrahedron with vertices O at the origin, A on the x-axis labelled 3, B on the y-axis labelled 4, and C on the z-axis labelled 1, with the x, y and z axes drawn and labelled.


I know every line equation as well.
The task is to calculate this integral as:
1. surface integral of outside of the area (in the picture)
2. using Ostrogradsky formula

Homework Equations



Equation of plane: 4x+3y+12z-12=0
It means that x=3-0.75y-3z and z=1-0.25y-(1/3)x

The Attempt at a Solution



I guess, this can be integral for task 1, when we use surface integral:
Handwritten-style double integral expression: integral from 0 to 1 of integral from 0 to -4z+4 of ((12-3y-12z)/4) dy dz, plus integral from 0 to 1 of integral from 0 to (12-3y)/4 of ((12-4x-3y)/12) dx dy.


Can someone chek, if it's correct? And how to start task 2, when I have to use Ostrogradsky formula?
 
Attachments
  • Closed surface integral symbol with the integrand x dy dz + z dx dy written beside it.
    1442jcycd8bb2e4ywox.png
    610 bytes · Views: 444
evol_w10lv said:

Homework Statement


I have got double contour integral:
Handwritten-style integral sign with a closed surface symbol followed by the expression x dy dz + z dx dy.

And here is picture:
3D coordinate diagram with axes x, y and z meeting at origin O; a triangle with vertices A on the x-axis at 3, B on the y-axis at 4, and C on the z-axis at 1, drawn with bold edges.


I know every line equation as well.
The task is to calculate this integral as:
1. surface integral of outside of the area (in the picture)
2. using Ostrogradsky formula

Homework Equations



Equation of plane: 4x+3y+12z-12=0
It means that x=3-0.75y-3z and z=1-0.25y-(1/3)x

The Attempt at a Solution



I guess, this can be integral for task 1, when we use surface integral:
Two iterated integrals in plain notation: integral from 0 to 1 of integral from 0 to -4z+4 of ((12-3y-12z)/4) dy dz, plus integral from 0 to 1 of integral from 0 to (12-3y)/4 of ((12-4x-3y)/12) dx dy.


Can someone chek, if it's correct? And how to start task 2, when I have to use Ostrogradsky formula?

What are we going to do with this evol? I have some questions and observations:

(1) Isn't the (real) double contour integral above just a surface integral?

(2) If this is a surface integral, then the double integrals you're written are not correct. The integrals you wrote are just simple volume integrals. Also, the outer limits of the second integral are incorrect for a volume integral: the upper limit on y is 4 and not 1.

(3) Your statement above, "1. surface integral of outside of the area (in the picture)" is not clear at all. What area? Do you mean the surface integral over the triangular region intersecting the axis planes? Would be better to say something like, compute the surface integral:

[tex]\mathop\iint\limits_{\text{Red}} x dS[/tex]

Where "red" is the surface in the plot below. What would that surface integral be?
 
Attachments
  • 3D plot of a red triangular surface spanning the x, y and z axes inside a wireframe box, with axis ticks from 0 to 4 on x, 0 to 3 on y and 0 to 1 on z.
    red triangle.jpg
    14.3 KB · Views: 467
Last edited:
I guess, it's just surfice integral.
It means that this is the correct solution:
Two iterated integrals added together and equal to 4: the first is the integral from 0 to 4 of the integral from 1 to 1 minus y/4 of (-3y/4 - 3z + 3) dz dy, the second is the integral from 0 to 3 of the integral from 0 to 4 minus 4x/3 of (-x/3 - y/4 + 1) dy dx, with a plus 2 term and an equals 4.
?

And what about Ostrogradsky formula?
 
evol_w10lv said:
I guess, it's just surfice integral.
It means that this is the correct solution:
Two iterated integrals added together equal 4: the first over y from 0 to 4 and z from 1 to 1 minus y/4 of (-3y/4 - 3z + 3), the second over x from 0 to 3 and y from 0 to 4 minus 4x/3 of (-x/3 - y/4 + 1), with the sum of 2 plus 2 equal to 4.
?

I don't think so. Remember the formula for a surface integral over the surface z=f(x,y)? It's

[tex]\mathop\iint\limits_S g(x,y,z)dS=\mathop\iint\limits_R g(x,y,f(x,y)) \sqrt{f_x^2+f_y^2+1}dA[/tex]
 
Hmm.. I tried to use this example:
Handwritten solution of a surface integral over a tetrahedron with vertices at the origin and on the z, y and x axes at 3, 2 and 3, with the plane 2x + 3y + 2z - 6 = 0 and the integrals I1 and I2 evaluated on the yz and xz projections.


Why in that case my solution is wrong?
 
evol_w10lv said:
Hmm.. I tried to use this example:
Handwritten solution of a surface integral over a tetrahedron cut by the plane 2x+3y+2z-6=0, with a 3D sketch of the tetrahedron on the axes marked 2, 3 and 3, and the split into I1 and I2 evaluated to 15/2.


Why in that case my solution is wrong?

Hi evol,

I don't wish to steer you wrong. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding what you're trying to do here. Those integrals above are just volume integrals and not what I believe are surface integrals. Maybe though I'm not understanding this problem.
 
Last edited:
I guess, I don't understand this problem as well.
I will try to find out, what exactly I have to calculate.