I proved a physics equation. Does any one know if theirs an equation like this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ambrose 2014
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Physics
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a pilot's problem involving vector addition to determine the necessary flight direction and ground velocity when landing at a lake affected by wind. The user presents a complex mathematical derivation to arrive at the required angle and speed, emphasizing the relationship between the plane's airspeed, wind speed, and the desired landing direction. Another participant critiques the approach as overly complicated for a straightforward vector addition problem and suggests using simpler methods, such as trigonometric laws. The conversation also touches on the distinction between proving concepts in physics versus mathematics, highlighting the challenges faced by a novice in physics. Overall, the thread illustrates the intersection of practical aviation problems with mathematical modeling.
Ambrose 2014
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Direction of a plane proof
48. A pilot wants to land at a small lake that is [N30.0 ̊W] of the airport that she is starting from. The wind has a velocity of 25.0 m/s[W] and the air speed of the plane is 1.90 × 10^2 m/s . What direction will the plane have to fly to get to its destination? What will be the velocity of the plane relative to the ground?

vt as the speed you'll achieve .
x as the plane speed or velocity.
w as wind speed or velocity.
Θ as the angle the plane has to go to achieve angle Φ at vt speed.
Φ as the angle away from start.

Know start to take the big picture coloured in red
vt^2=(xsinΘ+w)^2+(xcosΘ)^2
vt^2=(x^2sinΘ^2+wxsinΘ+wxsinΘ+w^2)+(x^2cosΘ^2)

now we have to get rid of the cosΘ^2 by taking(in green)
x^2=(x^2sinΘ^2)+(x^2cosΘ^2)
With x^2 divided
x^2/x^2=(x^2sinΘ^2)/x^2+(x^2cosΘ^2)/x^2
1=sinΘ^2+cosΘ^2
1-cosΘ^2=sinΘ^2
Now sub into the red coloured equation

vt^2=x^2(1-cosΘ^2)+wxsinΘ+wxsinΘ+w^2)+(x^2cosΘ^2)
vt^2=(x^2-x^2cosΘ^2)+(wxsinΘ+wxsinΘ+w^2)+(x^2cosΘ^2)
vt^2=x^2+2wxsinΘ^2+w^2

Now look at what's coloured in blue which is used to get rid of vt
sinΦ=(xsinΘ+w)/vt
(vt=(xsinΘ+w)/sinΦ)^2
vt^2=(x^2sinΘ^2+wxsinΘ+wxsinΘ+w^2)/sinΦ^2

Now we sub this equation into the red and green equation

(x^2sinΘ^2+2wxsinΘ+w^2)/sinΦ^2=x^2+2wxsinΘ+w^2

Move everything over to left

(x^2sinΘ^2/sinΦ^2)+(2wxsinΘ/sinΦ^2-2wxsinΘ)
(+w^2sinΦ^2-x^2-w^2)=0
A B C
Use the quadratic formula
sinΘ=-(2wx/sinΦ^2-2wx)+/-square root((2wx/sinΦ^2-2wx)^2-4x^2/sinΦ^2(w^2/sinΦ^2-x^2-w^2)/2x^2/sinΦ^2

sinΘ=(-2wx/sinΦ^2+2wx)+/-square root((4x^2w^2/sinΦ^4-4w^2x^2/sinΦ^2-4w^2x^2/sinΦ^2+4w^x^2)(-4x^2w^2/sinΦ^4+4x^4/sinΦ^2+4w^2x^2/sinΦ^2))/2x^2/sinΦ^2

sinΘ=(-2wx/sinΦ^2+2wx)+/-square root((-4w^2x^2/sinΦ^2+4w^x^2+4x^4/sinΦ^2))/2x^2/sinΦ^2

sinΘ=(-2wx/sinΦ^2+2wx)+/-square root((-4w^2x^2+4x^4)/sinΦ^2+4w^2x^2)/2x^2/sinΦ^2

multiply the whole equation by sinΦ^2
sinΘ=(-2wx+2wxsinΦ^2)+/-square root((-4w^2x^2+4x^4)sinΦ^2+4w^2x^2sinΦ^4)/2x^2
divid the equation by 2

sinΘ=(-wx+wxsinΦ^2)+/-
square root((-w^2x^2+x^4)sinΦ^2+w^2x^2sinΦ^4)/x^2
Divid by x
sinΘ=(-w+wsinΦ^2)+/-square root((-w^2+x^2)sinΦ^2+w^2sinΦ^4)/x

now say + not +/- and factor out sinΦ out of what's in the
Square root since we don't want a negative angle.

sinΘ=(-w+wsinΦ^2)+square root((-w^2+x^2+w^2sinΦ^2))sinΦ/x
Also written as

sinΘ=square root((-w^2+x^2+w^2sinΦ^2))sinΦ+(-w+wsinΦ^2)/x
if wind is in y direction
cosΘ=square root((-w^2+x^2+w^2cosΦ^2))cosΦ+(-w+wcosΦ^2)/x

x>w
If wind is going to opposite your going make negative.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Just as an aside on your problem, addressing your terminology. You cannot "prove" anything in physics, only in math, so if you proved it, it's math. Physics is always subject to disproof, math not so much.
 
Thank you for the advice I'm only in grade 11 and I didn't take physics yet
 
Ambrose 2014 said:
Thank you for the advice I'm only in grade 11 and I didn't take physics yet

Well, welcome to the forum
 
Hey thanks and this is my first time posting so that's why I didn't know what section to put my formula question in and by the way this is only for x direction the other one for cos I proved mathematically on paper but didn't type up yet.
 
It maybe long but I did so I can create an equation to solve problems like this since I like using equation and wouldn't sin and cosine laws work too
 
Back
Top