Ideal Gas Question in Thermodynamics

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around deriving the equation of state for an ideal gas in a tube where the temperature varies linearly from one end to the other. The temperature is defined by the equation T = To + [(TL - To)/L]x, where To and TL are the temperatures at the respective ends of the tube. Participants are tasked with showing how this leads to the equation PV=nR[(TL-To)/ln(TL/To)] and examining the case when To = TL.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the implications of the changing temperature and density in the gas, questioning how to relate these variables to derive the equation of state. There are attempts to express density as a function of position and pressure, and to integrate these relationships to find the number of moles in the tube.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided insights into the relationships between pressure, volume, and density, while others express confusion about how to proceed with the derivation. There is a mix of interpretations regarding the application of the ideal gas law and the integration of density over the volume of the tube.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the problem involves deriving relationships based on given equations and assumptions about the ideal gas behavior, with specific attention to the linear temperature gradient and its effects on density and pressure.

jrklx250s
Messages
15
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Given the temperature of an ideal gas in a tub where it varies linearly from (x=0) to (x=L)

T = To + [(TL - To)/L]x

where To is temperature at 0 length and TL is the temperature at the end of the tube

We are suppose to show that the equation of state for this ideal gas is

PV=nR[(TL-To)/ln(TL/To)]

As well as if then To = TL = T show that the equation of state reduces to the obvious one...PV=nRT



The Attempt at a Solution



So first off I wasnt sure of where to start because I know the only changing variable in this question is temperature so I know we are suppose to rearrange this equation
T = To + [(TL - To)/L]x

However I'm not sure on how to derive this equation.
Mostly this is alegbra/dervatives/integration problem.
And I'm honestly stuck as to where to go from the temperature equation
Any suggestions on where to begin would be greatly appreciative.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The gas is in rest so the pressure has to be constant in the whole volume, but the density of the gas changes according to the ideal gas law.
Write out the density as function of x and the constant pressure P and integral for the whole volume to get the amount of gas. ehild
 
Thanks for your reply, so I'm a little confused, the density is changing therefore we can write

σ(x) = Pdx
∫σ(x) = P∫dx
∫σ(x) = P(xL-x0)

But how does this help with the temperature equation?
 
jrklx250s said:
Thanks for your reply, so I'm a little confused, the density is changing therefore we can write

σ(x) = Pdx
∫σ(x) = P∫dx
∫σ(x) = P(xL-x0)

But how does this help with the temperature equation?

I do not know what your equation means, I thought of the ideal gas law, I guess you know what it is? And density as mass/volume.

ehild
 
Indeed,

PV=nRT

But my main question is how to derive T = To + [(TL - To)/L]x
To eventually make it into T = [(TL-To)/ln(TL/To)]

I'm lost as to where to even start in this derivation
 
jrklx250s said:
Indeed,

PV=nRT

But my main question is how to derive T = To + [(TL - To)/L]x
To eventually make it into T = [(TL-To)/ln(TL/To)]

I'm lost as to where to even start in this derivation

T = To + [(TL - To)/L]x is given, you can not derive it.

The problem is to find the equation of state of the ideal gas in that tube. That means the relation between P, V, he number of moles, and a quantity, you can call an effective temperature. The method is that you consider the tube as a couple of cells, each at the same pressure, and temperature as given at the position of the cell. You need to find the number of moles in each cell. For that, apply the ideal gas law PV=nRT for the cells. The number of moles in a volume element dV is equal to the density of moles multiplied by dV.
The density σ changes with temperature along the length of the tube, so you need a relation between temperature and density. σ=n/V. How is σ related to P and T?

ehild
 
Well since density is number of moles over volume
σ = n/v

and V = nRT/P

σ= P/RT

but I am unsure how this helps me because now I have the density at x=0 which is P/RTo and the density at x=L which is P/RTL
 
jrklx250s said:
Well since density is number of moles over volume
σ = n/v

and V = nRT/P

σ= P/RT

but I am unsure how this helps me because now I have the density at x=0 which is P/RTo and the density at x=L which is P/RTL

You have the density at every x if you substitute T = To + [(TL - To)/L]x into σ= P/RT. From the density at x, you can calculate the number of moles in a small slice of the tube of volume dV=Adx: it is dn=σdV. If you integrate dn with respect to x from x=0 to x=L, you get the number of moles in the tube, which has the volume V=AL.


ehild
 

Attachments

  • tube.JPG
    tube.JPG
    3.3 KB · Views: 446
Last edited:
I do not like when an interesting thread is interrupted without any feedback, so I do a few steps steps forward; hopefully, I will be more clear now.

The molar density of gas at x is n/V=σ=P/(RT)

The temperature was given as T(x) = To + [(TL - To)/L]x. Introducing the notation

b=(TL/To - 1)/L,

T(x)=To(1+bx).

Substituting for T(x) in the expression for the density:

σ=\frac{P}{RTo}\frac{1}{1+bx}

Taking a volume element as a slice of the tube with cross-section A and thickness dx, the number of moles in that volume is dn=σAdx. To get the number of moles in the tube, integrate dn with respect to x from 0 to L.

n=\frac{PA}{RTo} \int_0^L{\frac{1}{1+bx}dx}=\frac{PA}{bRTo} ln(1+bL)

Replacing back b=(TL-To)/(ToL), and using that AL=V, the volume of the gas,

n=\frac{PALTo}{(TL-TO)RTo} ln(1+(TL-To)/To)=\frac{PV}{R}\frac{ln(TL/To)}{TL-To}.

From here, the equation of state is obtained in the form PV=nRTeff, where Teff is some effective temperature, characterising the gas in the tube.

ehild
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 33 ·
2
Replies
33
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 35 ·
2
Replies
35
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K