History If you could question of any scientist in history

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ivan Seeking
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    History Scientist
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the intriguing idea of questioning historical scientists, highlighting personal anecdotes and hypothetical inquiries. A notable interaction with Stephen Hawking is recounted, where he was asked about his dream destination in the universe, to which he expressed a desire to explore inside a black hole. Participants reflect on the significance of their questions, with one suggesting a query to Charles Darwin about the fear of ostracism for his revolutionary theories, and another considering whether Gregor Mendel manipulated his experimental data. Additionally, there is curiosity about Dr. Eugene Shoemaker's findings during his last visit to the Tanami Desert. The conversation emphasizes the impact of these scientists' work and the personal connections formed through their inquiries.
Ivan Seeking
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
8,194
Reaction score
2,470
If you could question any scientist in history

Darn. Didn't get back in time to fix the title.

I recently heard a story about a tech at Femi Lab who found himself alone for a few minutes with Stephen Hawking. What would you say!?

Also, when I saw Hawking at the U of O some years ago, we all submitted a questions and ten were selected to be answered. I really had to think about my question; where to begin...?

If you could ask one question of any scientist from history, who and what would you ask.

My favorite question that was asked of Hawking: "If you could go anywhere in the universe, where would it be?" It seems that no one had ever asked him this before. His answer [effectively]: If somehow made possible, inside of a black hole.

Hawking asked the tech at Fermi Lab if he like his job. The tech said something like, "my job kind of sucks sometimes but the work is interesting". Hawking eventually replied: "Me too".

Hey Integral, if you are reading this, did I get that right? Did he actually say "sucks" to Hawking or did he just say that to us? Maybe he just said "boring".
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
"Hey Galileo, what do you think of Christians?"
 
I am not going to be able to top that, Dagenais!

I would ask Darwin, "Did you fear being ostracized by your community for providing a theory that was so at-odds with Biblical literalism?"

Second choice: I would ask Gregor Mendel if he fudged any of his data in his pea-plant experiments.
 
Einstein. I'd ask him if he really meant to write "Fast clock run slow." or if "Fast clocks will be measured as running slow" wouldn't have been a better way to put it.
 
Dr Eugene Shoemaker

I've conversed with many famous scientists over the years.

The one that I would like to ask just one more question of, is the late Dr Eugene Shoemaker.

I would ask him, "What did you find on your final visit to the Tanami Desert?"

I have my suspicions, but I'd like confirmation.

PS: I was the one who recently obtained (and posted) the Coroner's Report on Dr Eugene Shoemaker.
 
Dagenais said:
"Hey Galileo, what do you think of Christians?"

Galileo: Some, like me, are good. Some, like Ludovico delle Colombe, are bad.
 
"Now Mr. Fermat, here's a nice, empty notebook with lots of space in these pages..."
 

Similar threads

Replies
261
Views
21K
Replies
9
Views
781
Replies
18
Views
5K
Replies
23
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
15
Views
3K
Back
Top