Implicit Derivation: Finding 2nd Derivative of y^2 = x^3

9 replies · 3K views · last reply
Bashyboy
Messages
1,419
Reaction score
5

Homework Statement


I am suppose to find the second derivative implicitly of the function y^2 = x^3. I find the first derivative to be dy/dx = 3x^2/2y, but shortly find myself having difficulty in the second derivation. My steps for the second derivative is in the file attached; there are a few additionally steps, but, at the last step, I am in no way nearing the actual answer.


Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution

 
Attachments
  • Handwritten implicit differentiation of y^2 = x^3 in three rows: d2y/dx2 = (2y*6x - 3x^2*2dy/dx)/4y^2 simplifies to (12xy - 6x^2 dy/dx)/4y^2, then substitutes dy/dx = 3x^2/2y to get 12xy - 18x^4/2y over 4y^2, then 12xy - 4x^4y^-1 over 4y^2, then 3xy^-1(4y^0 - 3x^3)/4y^2, then 3x(4 - 3x^3)/4y^3, then 3x(4 - 3y^2)/4y^3.
    Untitled.jpg
    25 KB · Views: 617
Bashyboy said:

Homework Statement


I am suppose to find the second derivative implicitly of the function y^2 = x^3. I find the first derivative to be dy/dx = 3x^2/2y, but shortly find myself having difficulty in the second derivation. My steps for the second derivative is in the file attached; there are a few additionally steps, but, at the last step, I am in no way nearing the actual answer.
Handwritten implicit differentiation working in three rows: d2y/dx2 = (2y.6x - 3x^2.2 dy/dx)/4y^2 simplifying to (12xy - 6x^2 dy/dx)/4y^2; then substituting dy/dx = 3x^2/2y to get 12xy - 18x^3/2y, then 12xy - 9x^4 y^-1 over 4y^2; then 3xy^-1(4y^0 - 3x^3)/4y^2 simplifying to 3x(4 - 3x^3)/4y^3 and 3x(4 - 3y^2)/4y^3.


I assume that you result for implicitly differentiating y^2 = x^3, the first time was something like:
[itex]\displaystyle 2y(dy/dx)=3x^2[/itex]​
Differentiate that again before solving for dy/dx. It's easier to work with.
 
Well, I took the derivative from where you advised me to; but I still feel I am getting it wrong. Here are some of the steps I took, though there are few because I had the intuition that I was getting them wrong.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten implicit differentiation: 2y dy/dx = 3x^2 differentiated to 2 dy/dx + 2y d²y/dx² = 6x, then rewritten as 2y(6x²/2y + 2y d²y/dx²) = (6x)2y/1.
    Derivative.jpg
    12.7 KB · Views: 531
Bashyboy said:
Well, I took the derivative from where you advised me to; but I still feel I am getting it wrong. Here are some of the steps I took, though there are few because I had the intuition that I was getting them wrong.
Handwritten derivation: 2y dy/dx = 3x^2, then differentiating both sides with respect to x gives 2 dy/dx + 2y d^2y/dx^2 = 6x, followed by factoring 2y/1 out of the left side and rewriting as (6x) 2y/1.


That looks OK so far.
 
Well, the answer is 3x/4y, and I am still not getting this.
 
SammyS said:
Handwritten derivation: 2y dy/dx = 3x^2, then d/dx of both sides gives 2 dy/dx + 2y d^2y/dx^2 = 6x, then rewritten as 2y/1 times (6x^2/2y + 2y d^2y/dx^2) = (6x) 2y/1.


That looks OK so far.

You miss a square in the second step . d/dx(yy')=y'2+yy".

ehild
 
ehild, I am terribly sorry: I don't really understand what you are saying; I can't not see what it is that I should be fixing in my second step.
 
ehild, I believe you may have made a mistake when typing with latex.
 
Do again the derivative of y dy/dx. It is (dy/dx)2+yd2y/dx2.

ehild
 
SammyS said:
Handwritten derivation: 2y dy/dx = 3x^2 becomes d/dx[2y dy/dx] = d/dx[3x^2], then 2(dy/dx) + 2y d^2y/dx^2 = 6x, then (2y/1)(6x^2/2y + 2y d^2y/dx^2) = (6x)(2y/1).


[STRIKE]That looks OK so far[/STRIKE].
I was wrong. As ehild pointed out, the dy/dx should be squared.

[itex]\displaystyle \frac{d}{dx}(2y\frac{dy}{dx})=2\frac{dy}{dx}\frac{dy}{dx}+2y\frac{d^2y}{dx^2}[/itex]