Indeterminate Limits (L'Hopitals Rule)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jet1045
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Limits
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the application of L'Hôpital's Rule to evaluate limits that present indeterminate forms. The problems include limits involving trigonometric functions, exponential functions, and rational expressions, specifically focusing on forms such as ∞/∞, 0^0, and ∞^∞.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss various approaches to applying L'Hôpital's Rule, including taking derivatives and rewriting limits in different forms. Some express confusion over the forms of limits encountered and question their interpretations of indeterminate forms.

Discussion Status

Several participants have provided insights and suggestions for simplifying expressions and reapplying L'Hôpital's Rule. There is ongoing exploration of different methods to approach the problems, with some participants questioning their initial assumptions and interpretations of the limits.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the complexity of the problems and the potential influence of specific values (like the parameter 'a') on the limits. There is also mention of constraints related to the types of indeterminate forms discussed in class.

Jet1045
Messages
49
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Hey Everyone , i have 4 L'Hopital's rule problems that i am totally stuck on, and hints would be greatly appreciated. Ill just put all 4 here, and any help would be great.

1. lim x->a+ (cos(x)ln(x-a)) / ln(e^x - e^a)

Okay, so with this one i determined that it has the form ∞/∞. So i took the deriv of top and bottom.

and i got lim x->a+ [-sin(x)ln(x-a) + cos(x)/(x-a)] / [(e^x) / ( (e^x)-(e^a)].
When i substitute 0 i got ∞/0 . Which doesn't seem like a very good answer, so i don't know where i went wrong with my derivative.

2. lim x->0+ (tan2x)^x

This one would of course be in the form 0^0. So i know i need to so e^ lim x->0+ xln(tan2x). Which has the form 0(0) so i need to convert the indeterminate product into a quotient.
So i make lim x->0+ ln(tan2x)) / 1/x. This is form 0/0 so i applied l'hospital's and got:
lim x->0+ [(2(sec2x)^2)/tan2x] / -1/x^2

I kept getting indeterminate forms and reapplying l'hospital's but it seems to be getting no where, so i obviously messed up in the beginning and i can't see where.

3. lim x->∞ (e^x + x)^(1/x)

I realize that this problem is in the form ∞^0.
So i rewrote it as x->∞ ln(e^x + x)/x which has the type ∞/∞ so applied LH.
And got [e^x / (e^x + x)] / 1. When i substitue in i get ∞/1 Which isn't an indeterminate form, so is the answer just ∞. I know i would then have a final answer of e^∞. Which would be ∞.
This question is near the end of the textbook section, so i assumed it would be more difficult, but some confirmation here would be nice.

4. lim x->∞ [(2x-3)/(2x+5)]^(2x+1)
I treated this as an indeterminate power and got a whole lot of messy expansions, and such, so i think I am wayyy on the wrong track. But since the original limit would be ∞^∞ Is this still an indeterminate form? In class we only went over three indeterminate powers: 0^0 , ∞^0, and 1^∞. So I'm not even sure if this would be in an indeterminate form. Any help with this one would be great cause I'm totally lost.

If anyone, can help me on any of these i'd appreciate it. Thanks :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Jet1045 said:

Homework Statement



Hey Everyone , i have 4 L'Hopital's rule problems that i am totally stuck on, and hints would be greatly appreciated. Ill just put all 4 here, and any help would be great.

1. lim x->a+ (cos(x)ln(x-a)) / ln(e^x - e^a)

Okay, so with this one i determined that it has the form ∞/∞. So i took the derivative of top and bottom.

and i got lim x->a+ [-sin(x)ln(x-a) + cos(x)/(x-a)] / [(e^x) / ( (e^x)-(e^a)].
When i substitute 0 i got ∞/0 . Which doesn't seem like a very good answer, so i don't know where i went wrong with my derivative.

...

If anyone, can help me on any of these I'd appreciate it. Thanks :)
****************
Added in Edit:
I don't much like how the following turned out. It certainly looks like a fairly complicated problem.​
*****************

I'll start by responding to the first one.

Simplify your result.

\displaystyle \frac{-\sin(x)\ln(x-a) + \displaystyle \frac{\cos(x)}{x-a}}{\displaystyle \frac{e^x}{e^x-e^a}}


\displaystyle =\frac{\left(-\sin(x)\ln(x-a) + \displaystyle \frac{\cos(x)}{x-a}\right)\left(e^x-e^a\right)}{e^x}\quad\quad\quad\quad\quad\quad \text{#1}


\displaystyle =\frac{\left\{-(x-a)\sin(x)\ln(x-a) +\cos(x)\right\}\left(e^x-e^a\right)}{(x-a)e^x}\quad\quad\quad \text{#2}
The limit of expression #1 is of the form \displaystyle \frac{\pm(\infty\pm\infty)\cdot 0}{e^a}\,. We don't know what the value of the parameter, a, is, so we don't know the signs of sin(a) and cos(a).

The limit of expression #2 is of the form \displaystyle \frac{(\pm0\cdot\infty+\cos(a))(0)}{0}\,.

The above forms assume that sin(a) ≠ 0, cos(a) ≠ 0

In any case, you need to put your expression in a form suitable to use L'Hôpital's rule again.
 
Last edited:
Jet1045 said:
...

2. lim x->0+ (tan2x)^x

This one would of course be in the form 0^0. So i know i need to so e^ lim x->0+ xln(tan2x). Which has the form 0(0) so i need to convert the indeterminate product into a quotient.
So i make lim x->0+ ln(tan2x)) / 1/x. This is form 0/0 so i applied l'hospital's and got:
lim x->0+ [(2(sec2x)^2)/tan2x] / -1/x^2

I kept getting indeterminate forms and reapplying l'hospital's but it seems to be getting no where, so i obviously messed up in the beginning and i can't see where.
...
Actually lim x→0+ (x)ln(tan(2x)) is of the form 0∙(-∞) .

Take your result, \displaystyle \frac{2\sec^2(2x)}{-\tan(2x)(1/x^2)}\,, change sec(2x) to 1/cos(2x) and tan(2x) to sin(2x)/cos(2x) and multiply by x2/x2 & simplify.

Apply L'Hôpital's rule one more time.
 
Jet1045 said:
3. lim x->∞ (e^x + x)^(1/x)

I realize that this problem is in the form ∞^0.
So i rewrote it as x->∞ ln(e^x + x)/x which has the type ∞/∞ so applied LH.
And got [e^x / (e^x + x)] / 1. When i substitute in i get ∞/1 Which isn't an indeterminate form, so is the answer just ∞. I know i would then have a final answer of e^∞. Which would be ∞.
This question is near the end of the textbook section, so i assumed it would be more difficult, but some confirmation here would be nice.
I haven't looked at your solution in detail, but I get a different answer.

Try letting u = 1/x, and take the limit as u→0+

Added in Edit:

[e^x / (e^x + x)] / 1 is not of the form ∞/1.

[e^x / (e^x + x)] / 1 = [e^x / (e^x + x)] which is of the form ∞/∞.

Use L'Hôpital's rule again.
 
Last edited:
Jet1045 said:
...

4. lim x->∞ [(2x-3)/(2x+5)]^(2x+1)
I treated this as an indeterminate power and got a whole lot of messy expansions, and such, so i think I am wayyy on the wrong track. But since the original limit would be ∞^∞ Is this still an indeterminate form? In class we only went over three indeterminate powers: 0^0 , ∞^0, and 1^∞. So I'm not even sure if this would be in an indeterminate form. Any help with this one would be great cause I'm totally lost.
This is of the form (1) . That might remind you of lim (1+(1/n))n as n→∞ , which is one of the definitions of e, (Euler's constant).

You should be able to do it with e raised to the natural log of the limit. Alternatively, it can be done by using the definition of e .
 
Jet1045 said:
1. lim x->a+ (cos(x)ln(x-a)) / ln(e^x - e^a)
For this, I suggest letting u = x-a then, x = u + a .

Take the limit as u → 0+.

Use the angle addition identity for cos(u+a).

The result may be quite different if a is a multiple of π/2 . --- or perhaps an odd multiple of π/2 .
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
35
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K