# Homework Help: Internal Energy/Helmholtz Free Energy Proof

Tags:
1. Sep 27, 2015

### mobwars

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

Show that (∂(βA)/∂β)N,V = E, where A = E - TS is the Helmholtz Free Energy and E is the Internal Energy.

2. Relevant equations
A = E - TS
dE = TdS - pdV + ΣUidni
β = 1 / (kBT)

3. The attempt at a solution
(∂(βA)/∂β)N,V = (∂/∂β) * (βE - βTS)
(∂(βA)/∂β)N,V = (∂/∂β) * (βE - TS/(kBT))
(∂(βA)/∂β)N,V = (∂/∂β) * (βE - S/(kB))
(∂(βA)/∂β)N,V = (∂(βE)/∂β) [S/(kB) goes away because S is constant for Helmholtz Free Energy]
(∂(βA)/∂β)N,V = E

This solution just feels entirely too easy and simplified. I think you're supposed to do something with the fact that T and S are actual variables in the equation and some chain rule is needed, but that didn't seem to get me anywhere either. Anyone know what's really going on here?

2. Sep 27, 2015

### TSny

The two lines above are incorrect. As you suspected, S is not generally constant for a process in which N and V are kept constant.
Also, ∂(βE)/∂β ≠ E because E is not generally constant either.

It might help to make use of the first law as written in your second relevant equation.

3. Sep 27, 2015