gonegahgah
- 376
- 0
Can an electron traveling near the speed of light knock a proton or neutron out of a nucleus?
The discussion centers around the interactions between electrons and nucleons, specifically whether an electron traveling near the speed of light can knock a proton or neutron out of a nucleus. Participants explore various related phenomena, including nuclear transmutation, excitation, and deep inelastic scattering, while examining the energy dynamics involved in these processes.
Participants do not reach a consensus on whether an electron can effectively knock a nucleon out of a nucleus, and multiple competing views regarding the mechanisms and energy dynamics remain present throughout the discussion.
Participants highlight various terms and concepts related to nuclear interactions, but there is uncertainty regarding the applicability of these terms to the original question. The discussion also reflects limitations in understanding the energy scales and processes involved in nuclear reactions.
This discussion may be of interest to those studying particle physics, nuclear physics, or anyone curious about the interactions between subatomic particles and the energy dynamics of nuclear reactions.
gonegahgah said:Can an electron traveling near the speed of light knock a proton or neutron out of a nucleus?
The electron and bremsstrahlung photon energies that we are talking about here for nuclear transmutation are in the MeV region, so this energy corresponds to binding energies of nucleons. The deuteron binding (dissociation) energy is about 2.2 MeV, for example. The normal light scattering and "electron excitation and photon re-emission" you mention is an atomic, not nuclear, excitation process.gonegahgah said:Thanks BobS.
It is also the photons I am curious about as well.
I'm trying to get a feel for the intersize particle 'heftiness'.
Electrons have about 1/1836 the mass of of a proton (1/1839 of a neutron).
This makes it harder for electrons to push protons around I imagine than vice-versa; the electrons go where the proton goes; not vice-versa.
When hydrogen fuses to helium the conversion of mass to energy is about 1/142 the mass (a site said 0.7%; that is 1/142 isn't it?).
More mass than that contained in an electron is converted is it? Wow!
But that doesn't correspond to a single photon does it?
Afterall normal light scattering due to 'electron excitation and photon re-emission' doesn't correspond anywhere near that relative quantity of energy.