Is Andrea Worth $200 as a Plant-Based Air Purifier?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Evo
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Air
AI Thread Summary
The discussion critiques a product called Andrea, marketed as an innovative air purifier that utilizes a small fan and a plant to enhance air filtration. Participants express outrage over the $200 price tag for what they perceive as a simple plastic pot without an actual plant. Concerns are raised about the effectiveness of plants in air purification, with skepticism about the added fan's ability to improve their natural capabilities. Historical references are made to plants' roles in mitigating lead contamination, but the consensus leans toward viewing the product as overpriced and gimmicky. Comparisons to the pet rock phenomenon highlight the perceived absurdity of the product's marketing strategy, with some humorously suggesting that the concept is as trivial as a decorative item rather than a functional air purifier. Overall, the thread underscores a strong disbelief in the product's value and efficacy.
Evo
Staff Emeritus
Messages
24,029
Reaction score
3,323
This is outrageous. $200.00 for a small plastic plant pot with a tiny fan. Doesn't even include the plant. Has no air filters, nothing.

Product Description
Andrea is a revolutionary new air purifier engineered to significantly improve the air filtration capacity of natural plants. This living filter accelerates the removal of harmful VOC's and toxins through the active infrastructure system of a plant to continuously clean and oxygenate the rooms ion your home or foccie. Andrea naturally purifies air by drawing it in with a whisper quiet fan to propel it through the leaves and root system of a plant, then out through the water and soil filtration and back into the room . Works with any household plant. Ozone free operation. No replaceable filters.
$200.00

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002P8NZ1Q/?tag=pfamazon01-20

WTH is a foccie? Is that a dyslexic office?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
I was under the impression plants weren't very efficient at this sort of thing?

The plant can only process a certain amount, sticking a fan in isn't going to make it magically process more CO2 and give you cleaner air.
 
jarednjames said:
I was under the impression plants weren't very efficient at this sort of thing?

The plant can only process a certain amount, sticking a fan in isn't going to make it magically process more CO2 and give you cleaner air.

That's not about just CO2. I recall reading that back in the times of the leaded petrol trees planted on the sides of the road were substantially slowing process of lead contamination of the surrounding terrain. No idea about exact mechanism. I guess that's the idea behind the device. But I agree with Evo, it sounds ridiculous.
 
Dang plant huggers, no wonder my computer fan cost a fortune. I shudder to think what it will cost to put a catalytic converter on my grill this summer.
 
Chronos said:
Dang plant huggers, no wonder my computer fan cost a fortune. I shudder to think what it will cost to put a catalytic converter on my grill this summer.
:smile:

I can't believe more people haven't realized this is just a potted plant...without even the plant!
 
Borek said:
That's not about just CO2. I recall reading that back in the times of the leaded petrol trees planted on the sides of the road were substantially slowing process of lead contamination of the surrounding terrain. No idea about exact mechanism. I guess that's the idea behind the device. But I agree with Evo, it sounds ridiculous.

In the case of lead from petrol fumes, it settles into the soil where it can be taken up by fast-growing, "thirsty" trees. This is done however, using their extensive root system, not their leaves for the most part. So, you're right, and you're right!
 
Evo said:
:smile:

I can't believe more people haven't realized this is just a potted plant...without even the plant!

Any time I find myself in that state of incredulity you seem to be experiencing (it stinks I know)... I say two words out loud, and EVERYTHING becomes clear... and calm.

Pet. Rock.
 
nismaratwork said:
Pet. Rock.
I'd rather have the rock than a house-plant in a $200 enclosure.
 
turbo-1 said:
I'd rather have the rock than a house-plant in a $200 enclosure.

Yeah, but the principle is shockingly similar. I mean, plants, AFAIK grow like weeds! :rolleyes: So you can just fill your place with the darned things!

Rocks are also readily available, and between some pots, fans, nail polish, glue, and googly eyes... you have the makings of a fortune based on fools.

After all, the time and effort needed to produce and market pet rock was absurdly low... here you DO have a valid place to plant something, and a fan. It's a stupid concept, but it actually DOES something given the chance.

A pet rock... my god, is there ANYTHING that just screams, "kill me, I'm tired and lonely... my only friend is Rocky Balboa II... kiiiilllll mmmmeeeeee..." :approve:
 
  • #10
I'd prefer the rock, but for $200 I'd want it to be solid gold.
 
  • #11
jarednjames said:
I'd prefer the rock, but for $200 I'd want it to be solid gold.


ad_ep006_21.jpg



Will this suffice? It's not exactly a ROCK however...
 
  • #12
Hmm, gold coloured, glowing, inspires awe/fear in those who view it.

Yep, that would be just fine. I'll take two.
 
  • #13
jarednjames said:
Hmm, gold coloured, glowing, inspires awe/fear in those who view it.

Yep, that would be just fine. I'll take two.

Well, to be fair, in the context of the show it also brings death and misery to all who hold it... and you're a nice guy. So... eh. :wink:
 

Similar threads

How Can We Deal w/ Volatile Organic Compounds in Homes?
Replies
10
Views
2K
News Air Purifiers are a Ripoff - Whirlpool ap51030k
Replies
18
Views
42K
How many 0.3 micron particles in 0.1L volume of room air?
Replies
2
Views
5K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top