Is Carl Friedrich Gauss Really the Prince of Mathematicians?

  • Thread starter Thread starter matematikawan
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
Carl Friedrich Gauss is often referred to as the "prince of mathematicians," but this title raises questions about the gendered language used in his famous quote, "Mathematics is the Queen of the Sciences." The discussion highlights that in various languages, the nouns for mathematics and science have different gender associations, which may influence interpretations of Gauss's statement. It suggests that Gauss's use of "science" may refer to knowledge rather than the strict definition of science as understood today. Additionally, there is skepticism regarding Gauss's prominence in mathematics, with some arguing that his reluctance to publish diminishes his contributions compared to other mathematicians. Overall, the conversation reflects on the complexities of language and the perception of Gauss's legacy in the mathematical community.
matematikawan
Messages
336
Reaction score
0
Carl Friedrich Gauss is known as the "prince of mathematicians" in mathematics literature. But I think something is not right with this quotation from him.
"Mathematics is the Queen of the Sciences".

Is maths gender female?
Is maths a science?
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
In some languages (and Gauss spoke all of them, they say), nouns are in fact associated with a gender. In french for instance, "Science" is "feminine".
 
And saying that "Mathematics is the Queen of Sciences" does not necessarily mean mathematics is itself a science! It is not at all uncommon for the queen, or even king, of a country to be from another country.
 
It may also be a word by word translation from German where both <mathematics> and <queen> are feminine when it comes to noun's gender.
 
Yeah, probably a language thing as far as the gender goes. i.e. In Spanish, Mathematics is "La Matematica". 'La' implies feminine.
 
In my language (Malay) we usually don't give a gender for non human subject. So when I saw the word by word translation of that quotation, I was wondering why the word 'queen' is there. But it seem not a problem in other languages.

My understanding from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematics" , what Gauss meant by 'science' here is knowledge not the usual science that we know. Can I just interprete what Gauss said as "Mathematics is the pinnacle of knowledge" or something simailar (please do correct me) so that I can translate the quotation correctly to my language.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Rather than that, you should ask yourself why they call the "prince of mathematics". In my opinion, he is largely overrated. He might have been a mathematician of the first rank, but with his reluctance to publish he did not serve the cause as much as other mathematicians did. I suspect his so called greatness to be some kind of Anglo-German exaggeration, but that's another story.
 
Back
Top