Is it better to learn from another student or from a textbook?

  • Studying
  • Thread starter pivoxa15
  • Start date
  • #1
2,255
1
If you had the option of learning some material from a textbook or from another undergad student who has done the subject the previous year, which would you choose?

Or is it better do learn from the textbook and ask questions when it comes up?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
MathematicalPhysicist
Gold Member
4,359
241
can't you manage doing both?
i mean i dont see how do you have here an option of exclusive 'or'.
 
  • #3
2,255
1
Both is probably best. But I might get some false information from the student? ALthough interactive learning is best. If I can only choose one then which one?
 
  • #4
MathematicalPhysicist
Gold Member
4,359
241
well if he is an A's student then probably he knows something about the material, wether he knows all of it i dont know.
luckily, or unfortuanetly (depends on how do you see it) i still havent yet taken help from real person, unless youre including internet forums.
but if you already get help like from the internet, then shouldnt you be less worried if the help is from a real person.
i mean in the internet no one assures you that the help is coming from a genuine place, but you asill ask for advice.
this question sounds silly. (-:
 
  • #5
905
4
Both is probably best. But I might get some false information from the student? ALthough interactive learning is best. If I can only choose one then which one?
This is true, which is why it's important to think critically. Your learning should ideally come from your professor and TA, your textbook, and your fellow students. Rather than talking to students who've already taken the class, it's far better to learn the material alongside current students. When I was an undergrad, I got good grades largely because of my study groups.
 
  • #6
2,255
1
well if he is an A's student then probably he knows something about the material, wether he knows all of it i dont know.
luckily, or unfortuanetly (depends on how do you see it) i still havent yet taken help from real person, unless youre including internet forums.
but if you already get help like from the internet, then shouldnt you be less worried if the help is from a real person.
i mean in the internet no one assures you that the help is coming from a genuine place, but you asill ask for advice.
this question sounds silly. (-:
If I was just asking someone a question than it's okay if it is a student or on an internet forum because I would have thought about the contents in the question. But I was thinking of learning something completely new either from another student or from a textbook. I don't think people here would teach me something from scratch and plus it would be too inefficient to do so, unless we are messenging each other but it would still be more difficult than learning from a text in this situation.
 
Last edited:
  • #7
322
0
studnet - if its free........

go for the cheaper option.......
 
  • #8
radou
Homework Helper
3,115
6
Textbook.

Because you'll develop your way of understanding some things.
 
  • #9
JasonRox
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2,314
3
Textbook.

Because you'll develop your way of understanding some things.
Agreed.

Although it might be slower, it's probably the best way.
 
  • #10
radou
Homework Helper
3,115
6
Agreed.

Although it might be slower, it's probably the best way.
I know some people who achieve great results in some subjects, but I'll never ask them anything related to that very subject, because I know their way of thinking confuses me. It's not "advanced", it's just different.

Save time and energy.
 
  • #11
Textbook because I can reread a page over and over for 30 minutes if I have to but I doubt I could convince any of my friends to repeat themselves for 30 minutes.
 
  • #12
182
0
whoever explains simpler.....
 
  • #13
Dr Transport
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2,449
590
Both, you need to see how it is developed in a text then to ensure that you understand talk to another student. I learn more from my co-workers than from anything written by my employer.
 
  • #14
JasonRox
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2,314
3
Both, you need to see how it is developed in a text then to ensure that you understand talk to another student. I learn more from my co-workers than from anything written by my employer.
We're talking about a high school student here.
 
  • #15
2,255
1
University undergrad students actually.
 
  • #16
1,425
1
Textbooks. You need to learn from the masters.
 
  • #17
664
3
There is no reason that you cannot combine them all. There is a reason why we have an education system and not just textbooks.
 
  • #18
Dr Transport
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2,449
590
We're talking about a high school student here.
Doesn't matter, you learn from both sources almost equally. Whether in High School, University, Graduate School or workforce, you learn from multiple sources constantly.
 
  • #19
JasonRox
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2,314
3
Doesn't matter, you learn from both sources almost equally. Whether in High School, University, Graduate School or workforce, you learn from multiple sources constantly.
I found that I learned so much more when going through myself. I learned many valuable skills.
 
  • #20
2,255
1
Maybe it's best to learn the material from scratch from a textbook than ask the student and people here about any questions I might have.
 
  • #21
JasonRox
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2,314
3
Maybe it's best to learn the material from scratch from a textbook than ask the student and people here about any questions I might have.
Personally, I think the best you'll ever get is someone you can have conversations with about the subjects you'll learning. You learn a lot this way. Because you're teaching (telling your friend), learning (listening), and having a good time (if you like it). I learn more when I teach someone. I see all the holes in my thought process.

I'm dying to have someone to converse with. For example, right now I just read about Homotopy and Path-Homotopy and going into the Fundamental Group of Topological Spaces, and I'm absolutely dying to converse with someone about ideas, neat things, problems, etc... Like, it kills me to do this all by myself sometimes.
 
  • #22
mathwonk
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2020 Award
11,098
1,302
it is better to learn than not to learn.
 

Related Threads on Is it better to learn from another student or from a textbook?

Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
8K
Replies
4
Views
5K
Replies
8
Views
9K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
473
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
12
Views
751
Top