Prabesh Pokharel
If so how can we do that?
The discussion centers on the question of whether it is possible to bend a laser beam, exploring various methods and theoretical considerations related to light manipulation. Topics include refraction, reflection, and the implications of gravitational lensing, as well as advanced concepts such as graded refractive index materials and self-bending beams.
Participants present multiple competing views on how to bend a laser beam, with no consensus reached on the most effective or practical method. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best approach and the original poster's intent.
There are limitations regarding the assumptions made about the original poster's knowledge level and intended application, as well as the dependence on specific conditions for some proposed methods.
Or a star.jbriggs444 said:You can refract it with a lens or a prism.
DaveC426913 said:Or a star.
But for some smaller applications that might be impractical.
yup, but a really awesome and cool scaleboneh3ad said:I mean, isn't that technically still a (gravitational) lens, though?
Of course, in the case of a gravitational lens, the light is technically traveling in a straight line and we merely regard it as bent because of our prejudice toward the expected behavior of a space-time free from intrinsic curvature.boneh3ad said:I mean, isn't that technically still a (gravitational) lens, though?
I suspect that's a bit too advanced for this OPjbriggs444 said:Of course, in the case of a gravitational lens, the light is technically traveling in a straight line and we merely regard it as bent because of our prejudice toward the expected behavior of a space-time free from intrinsic curvature.
Yeah. The reason I mentioned it is that it is a lens that does not require the light to pass through - and be degraded by - a medium.boneh3ad said:I mean, isn't that technically still a (gravitational) lens, though?
Perhaps, but it might be unfair to second-guess the OP. They gave no clues about the intended application, or level of knowledge.phinds said:I suspect that's a bit too advanced for this OP
Based on the original question, I stand by my statement.DaveC426913 said:Perhaps, but it might be unfair to second-guess the OP. They gave no clues about the intended application, or level of knowledge.
A gradual change between different refractive indices will make a laser beam follow a Curved Path, which could be a bit more striking than a sharp kink on the way through. For that to happen (visibly) in air, you would need a long path and some extreme differences in temperature for two layers. But a laser beam can carry a long way and be visible from the side (dust scattering etc) so it may be realisable. Perhaps a fuzzy boundary between two miscible liquids would work.CWatters said:Material with graded refractive index. See also mirage.
I am shocked, shocked to find that is going on in here.phinds said:Anybody notice how we are just talking to ourselves here? The OP has not been back in the 8 days since he posted the question.