News Is Public Interest Waning in Canadian Election Debates?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bensprott
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The debate highlighted the strengths of Layton and Duceppe, with Layton being praised for his integrity and Duceppe for his strong performance in French, despite neither being likely to win the election. Harper and Ignatieff were seen as unconvincing, with the expectation that one of them would ultimately win due to their party affiliations. The Bloc Québécois was criticized for not being a true federal party, focusing only on Quebec interests. Concerns were raised about the election being a waste of taxpayer money if Harper secured a minority government again. The discussion also touched on the importance of local candidates over party leaders in Canadian elections, with some expressing disappointment in the election outcomes, particularly the Liberal Party's losses and Ignatieff's defeat in his own riding. Overall, the conversation reflected skepticism about the election's impact and the effectiveness of the current political leaders.
bensprott
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Is anyone watching the debate?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Watched it. The thing is the 2 best debaters have no chance of winning. Layton was really at ease, and Duceppe was great (considering the language difficulty. In French, he's really strong.)

Neither Harper or Ignatief were convincing, but of course, there is no doubt one of them will win the election, because they're from the only parties that aren't utopic.
 
Layton is and always has been one of the most stand-up guys I've seen in politics. If he were head of any other party, he'd surely win by a landslide.
 
I am not going to vote, neither interested but I heard Layton was good.
 
The Bloc isn't a Canadian Federal party ( Provincial only ) and should not have been there.

I almost wish Duceppe was a Canadian and a Liberal, he seems like the smartest of the bunch.
 
Alfi said:
The Bloc isn't a Canadian Federal party ( Provincial only ) and should not have been there.

I almost wish Duceppe was a Canadian and a Liberal, he seems like the smartest of the bunch.

Technically, the Bloc is a "Federal" party in the sense that it is built to play on the federal scene. But it only has candidates in Quebec, so its aspirations are not to govern Canada, only to "bloc" the winning government to pass any legislation that they see to be detrimental to Quebec.

The "Parti Quebecois" is the provincial counter-part that made the 2 historic referendums. It is a serious contender but it seems to have lacked convincing leadership in recent years.
 
Advance pools open today.

I haven't seen anything different in the talk from the leaders to indicate to me that anything different will result from this re-election.

I think it's all a waste of taxpayers money.
 
Alfi said:
I haven't seen anything different in the talk from the leaders to indicate to me that anything different will result from this re-election.
The ousting of the Harper government?
 
If Harper gets reelected with a minority government, then it's a waste of taxpayer money. If the result is anything different, then it's not.

Incidently, a former colleague of mine (and physicist/researcher) is actually running in these elections. It's rare enough to see scientists running.
 
Last edited:
  • #10
As always, I will vote for the best person for the job in my riding.
Even though I do not like his leader, I will not vote for less than the best, just to try and change what Party is running the country.

We, as Canadians do not vote for the leader in these elections, only the local candidates of the various parties.
The Party with the most winners gets to be the government.
I wonder if it would be different if we only voted for the leader.My wife is working in the polls for this election. She tells me it was very busy at her location.
 
  • #11
Dr Lots-o'watts said:
If Harper gets reelected with a minority government, then it's a waste of taxpayer money. If the result is anything different, then it's not.

Doesn't look like NOT going to be a waste of money. :(
 
  • #12
Majority Government

NDP opposition
The Bloc lost it's leader
The Libs lost their leader Wow. that was almost worth the money
 
  • #13
Well, you wanted to be around when the robots rose up and crushed their creators.

It's a Harper majority...
 
  • #14
Wow! This was quite a surprise. I expected NDP to gain quite a lot but didn't expect them to come in second place! Liberals were crushed which is somewhat surprising but Ignatieff losing his own riding! wow, didn't expect that!. I for one am happy the Block Quebecois got owned. Gill Duceppe is a separatist tyrant.
As usual my province voted conservative..nothing surprising there. Guess what province that is?
 
  • #15
kraphysics said:
... Ignatieff losing his own riding!
As a member of that riding I can attest that he was jammed in here in the first place, in his first bid at Prime Minister, and we didn't know where he came from - and he has been increasingly called 'the absentee candidate'. We never see him.
 
  • #16
DaveC426913 said:
As a member of that riding I can attest that he was jammed in here in the first place, in his first bid at Prime Minister, and we didn't know where he came from - and he has been increasingly called 'the absentee candidate'. We never see him.

what was he doing then? it seems like an arrogant/foolish thing to do for someone new to Canadian politics.
 
  • #17
kraphysics said:
what was he doing then? it seems like an arrogant/foolish thing to do for someone new to Canadian politics.

An excellent question.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top