Is the derivative in my textbook correct here?

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
whitejac
Messages
169
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Textbook page on the principle of conservation of energy: T + U = constant, then d/dt(T + U) = 0 as Eq. (2.6), with T = (1/2)mx-dot^2 (2.7), U = (1/2)kx^2 (2.8), and m x-double-dot + kx = 0 (2.3).


Homework Equations


d/dx

The Attempt at a Solution


d/dx (T) = d/dx(1/2mx'2) = mx''
d/dx(U) = d/dx(1/2kx2) = kx' ≠ kx

It's probably me who made an error because I know that that equation (2.3) is the one I should be getting, but I don't understand how they did it because potential energy relies on position, so the derivative has to be a velocity vector.
 
Here x is a function of t and the derivatives should be with respect to t. That's what x' implies.
 
(2.6) shows differentiation with respect to time. Your working is erroneously using differentiation with respect to x.
 
Oh right, it's x(t)... I guess the caffeine hasn't kicked in because that was really basic. Thank you!
 
I think (2.3) starts out as ##m \ddot x \dot x + k x \dot x = 0## and the common factor ##\dot x## can be canceled from both sides.