Is there a place in space where there is no energy?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cragar
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Energy Space
AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores whether there are regions in space devoid of energy or stars. It highlights that measuring energy inherently adds energy to the system, making it impossible to confirm a complete absence of energy. Observations of stars involve interactions that contribute energy, complicating the idea of "empty" space. The conversation also touches on the challenges of defining and measuring energy in specific regions of space, especially as the universe expands. Ultimately, the consensus suggests that energy is pervasive throughout space.
cragar
Messages
2,546
Reaction score
3
This may be a dumb question . My friend asked me is there a place in space where there is no energy .And then he said
is there a place in space where you can't see any stars . Do gravitational fields have energy densities .
So is there a place in space that has no energy ?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
cragar said:
This may be a dumb question . My friend asked me is there a place in space where there is no energy .And then he said
is there a place in space where you can't see any stars . Do gravitational fields have energy densities .
So is there a place in space that has no energy ?

You can't test whether or not a region is devoid of energy. As soon as you measure something, you add energy to it. If you can't test a theory, it's not scientific.
 
Tac-Tics said:
You can't test whether or not a region is devoid of energy. As soon as you measure something, you add energy to it. If you can't test a theory, it's not scientific.

If I am observing a star through a telescope, how am I adding energy to that star?
 
if you think about the size of your eye's iris, and the amount of starlight that enters it on a cloudless night, then think that some star light (energy) is also passing through just about every millimeter of space. Space isn't at absolute zero either.
 
pallidin said:
If I am observing a star through a telescope, how am I adding energy to that star?

You're definitely interacting with the star when the light hits your eye. Maybe I'm playing fast and loose, equating "space" with "system".

If you're taking a measuring on a region of space (and not a system of particles), you have the additional difficulty that your measurement must be made instantaneously. By naming spatial bounding box for a region in your coordinate system, you can specify what "space" you're talking about. But an instant later, it's unclear whether or not the same bounding box refers to the "same space".
 
so then energy is everywhere.
 
If energy is everywhere , and space is expanding , then where does this energy come from to fill the void .
 

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
201
Replies
20
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
4K
Back
Top