curious2021
- 3
- 1
The discussion revolves around the nature of patterns observed in a photograph of curtains, specifically whether they represent diffraction patterns or Moiré patterns. Participants explore the similarities and differences between these types of patterns, considering aspects of optical interference, color fringes, and the effects of camera sensors.
Participants do not reach a consensus on whether the patterns are primarily Moiré or diffraction patterns. Multiple competing views remain regarding the nature of the observed patterns and the underlying mechanisms.
Participants express varying interpretations of the relationship between Moiré patterns and diffraction, highlighting potential limitations in definitions and the complexity of the phenomena being discussed.
Thanks for the reply. I’m confused though. My reading of the Moire pattern is that it’s caused by two overlapping patterns which produce multiple slits that the light passes through, diffracts and interferes, producing an interference pattern? So Moire patterns are really interference patterns? From what you’ve said though, it sounds like I’ve read that article wrong?sophiecentaur said:Diffraction patterns and Moiré patterns have a lot in common and it can be difficult to distinguish between them. @Motore has assumed that the patterns are Moiré and they may well be (so not optical diffraction) but there are colours around those fringes, which implies there's some wavelength dependence. You will probably see some of that patterning in diffuse lighting (which doesn't support visible diffraction fringing well. There may be 'beats' between the thread spacing and the regular variation of colours along the threads themselves.
I suggest it's a bit of both because some of the fringes have coloured edges. But also there is clear colouration in the irregularities elsewhere in the picture.
If you want to see diffraction patterns through fabric then look at distant street lights (pinpoints of light) and you can get all sorts of repeated dot patterns. See this link for some pretty patterns, including curtain diffraction.
They are the result of the interaction of two patterns which, with a different hat on, is the same as optical interference where two wave patterns add together in different ways in different places. I guess you could say that there is interference in both cases but diffraction only in the optical case.curious2021 said:So Moire patterns are really interference patterns?
Hah - I spotted it but not sure if I can actually explain it!curious2021 said:great spot on the color too.
[Edit: important to know I'm talking about my Pentax SDSLR]. There is no blur filter (Anti-aliasing) but, if you are taking critical pictures where the moiré is noticeable, the sensor is vibrated (same motors used as for dust elimination and star tracking). Cool eh?Orthoceras said:In high resolution cameras the color moire effect is less conspicuous, and no blur filter is needed.
I think in this case that one pattern is the curtains (mesh with the threds) and the other is the camera sensor. (I see @Orthoceras beat me to it)curious2021 said:My reading of the Moire pattern is that it’s caused by two overlapping patterns
It looks to me like the lines of threads and the pattern on the threads themselves. This can be resolved if the OP saw the patterns before he took the picture.Motore said:I think in this case that one pattern is the curtains (mesh with the threds) and the other is the camera sensor. (I see @Orthoceras beat me to it)
https://photographylife.com/what-is-moire