Kirchhoff's Rules. Solving for currents in circuit with two batteries

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
Painguy
Messages
118
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Circuit schematic with two batteries and three 4 Ω resistors: BAT2 (10 V) on the left branch, R1 on the top wire, R2 and series BAT1 (5 V) in the middle branch, and R3 on the right. Currents labelled i1, i2 and i3 with arrows.


What are the sizes and directions of the currents through
resistors (a) R2 and (b) R3 in Fig. 27-42, where each of the three resistances is 4.0 Ω?

Homework Equations


ΔV=IR


The Attempt at a Solution


Equations:
1) ΔVB2 -(i1)R1 -(i2)R2 -ΔVB1=0
5V - 4(i1) - 4(i2) =0
4(i2)=5V -4(i1)

2) ΔVB2 -(i1)R1 -(i3)(R3)=0
10V -4(i1) -4(i3) =0
-4(i3)=-10V + 4(i1)

not sure about this one
3) ΔVB1 -(i2)R2 -(i3)(R3)=0
5V + 4(i2) -4(i3) =0

4) i1=i2 + i3

5V +5V -4(i1) -10V +4(i1)=0
0=0

I'm not really sure what to do here.
 
Last edited:
Painguy said:

Homework Statement



Circuit schematic with two loops: BAT2 10 V on the left branch with R1 4 Ω on top, R2 4 Ω in series with BAT1 5 V in the middle branch, and R3 4 Ω on the right. Currents labelled i1, i2 and i3 with arrows.


What are the sizes and directions of the currents through
resistors (a) R2 and (b) R3 in Fig. 27-42, where each of the three resistances is 4.0 Ω?

Homework Equations


ΔV=IR


The Attempt at a Solution


Equations:
1) ΔVB2 -(i1)R1 -(i2)R2 -ΔVB1=0
5V - 4(i1) - 4(i2) =0
4(i2)=5V -4(i1)

2) ΔVB2 -(i1)R1 -(i3)(R3)=0
10V -4(i1) -4(i3) =0
-4(i3)=-10V + 4(i1)

not sure about this one
3) ΔVB1 -(i2)R2 -(i3)(R3)=0
5V + 4(i2) -4(i3) =0

4) i1=i2 + i3

[STRIKE]5V +5V -4(i1) -10V +4(i1)=0
0=0[/STRIKE]

I'm not really sure what to do here.

The blue equation is not independent from the previous ones. Use eq.4 to find i1.

ehild
 
I also suggest superposition:
solve for the currents with one battery shorted, solve with the other battery shorted, then add the results.