Length of Curve: Finding r(t) Derivative

  • Thread starter Thread starter monnapomona
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Curve Length
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around finding the length of a curve defined by the vector function r(t) = e-2t i + e-2tsin(t) j + e-2tcos(t) for the interval 0 ≤ t ≤ 2π. Participants are exploring the differentiation of the vector function and the subsequent calculation of the length using the integral of the magnitude of the derivative.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss factoring out e-2t from the derivative and question whether it can be done. There are attempts to differentiate the components of the vector function, with some participants expressing confusion about the correct application of the product rule and the integration process for the length formula.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with participants providing guidance on differentiation and integration techniques. There is a recognition of the need for clarity in the expressions used for the derivative and the length calculation. Some participants are questioning the correctness of their integration steps and the final expressions derived.

Contextual Notes

Participants are navigating through the complexities of vector calculus, specifically focusing on the length of a curve and the implications of differentiating vector functions. There is an emphasis on ensuring proper notation and understanding the relationship between the position vector, its derivative, and the concept of length in the context of integrals.

monnapomona
Messages
39
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Find the length of the curve:

r(t) = e-2t i + e-2t*sin(t) j + e-2t*cos(t) k, 0 ≤ t ≤ 2π


Homework Equations



L = ∫\stackrel{b}{a} |r'(t)|

The Attempt at a Solution



I tried factoring out e-2t and got:

e-2t (i + sin(t) j + cos(t) k)

This is where I got lost. Can I take the derivative this and just leave e-2t outside of the brackets?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Yes, differentiate the whole thing.
 
haruspex said:
Yes, differentiate the whole thing.

Okay, would this right?

-2e-2t (1 + cos(t) - sin(t))
 
monnapomona said:

Homework Statement


Find the length of the curve:

r(t) = e-2t i + e-2t*sin(t) j + e-2t*cos(t) k, 0 ≤ t ≤ 2π

Homework Equations



L = ∫\phantom{|}_{a}^{b} |r'(t)|

The Attempt at a Solution



I tried factoring out e-2t and got:

e-2t (i + sin(t) j + cos(t) k)

This is where I got lost. Can I take the derivative this and just leave e-2t outside of the brackets?

Hello monnapomona. Welcome to PF !

e-2t can be outside of the brackets, but can't be taken out of the integrand. But it may be better not to factor it out. Either way, you will need to use the product rule.

That integral needs the differential, dt:
\displaystyle \int_{0}^{2\pi}\left|\textbf{r}'(t)\right|\,dt​
What is \displaystyle \left|\textbf{r}'(t)\right|\ ?
 
monnapomona said:
Okay, would this right?

-2e-2t (1 + cos(t) - sin(t))
What's the derivative of f(t)g(t)?
 
haruspex said:
What's the derivative of f(t)g(t)?

I think it would be f'(t)g(t) + g'(t)f(t).

I tried not factoring out e-2t from the vector function and got this

r'(t) = e-2t - 2e-2tsin(t) +e-2tcos(t) - e-2tsin(t) - 2e-2tcos(t)


I'm lost on what to do next... :s
 
monnapomona said:
I think it would be f'(t)g(t) + g'(t)f(t).

I tried not factoring out e-2t from the vector function and got this

r'(t) = e-2t - 2e-2tsin(t) +e-2tcos(t) - e-2tsin(t) - 2e-2tcos(t)

I'm lost on what to do next... :s

Where are the unit vectors?
 
SammyS said:
Where are the unit vectors?

Oh, whoops.

r'(t) = e-2t i - 2e-2tsin(t)+e-2tcos(t) j - e-2tsin(t) - 2e-2tcos(t) k

I'm not sure if this is okay to do but I tried factoring out the e-2t and got

r'(t) = e-2t ( i - 2sin(t) + cos(t) j - sin(t) - 2cos(t) k )
 
It looks like the i part is wrong so you may want to doublecheck.

But I'm not sure why you stopped there :) Length of a vector is...
 
  • #10
SammyS said:
Where are the unit vectors?

aralbrec said:
It looks like the i part is wrong so you may want to doublecheck.

But I'm not sure why you stopped there :) Length of a vector is...

Oh yeah! okay hopefully this is right:

r'(t) = -2e-2t i - 2e-2tsin(t)+e-2tcos(t) j - e-2tsin(t) - 2e-2tcos(t) k

i'm a little confused on how to do length...
Could I square each vector like (i, j, k) and just add what I get for it together?
 
  • #11
monnapomona said:
Oh yeah! okay hopefully this is right:

r'(t) = -2e-2t i - 2e-2tsin(t)+e-2tcos(t) j - e-2tsin(t) - 2e-2tcos(t) k

That looks right. I would have kept the exponential factored out to make it easier to take the magnitude.

i'm a little confused on how to do length...
Could I square each vector like (i, j, k) and just add what I get for it together?

Yes and take square root. This vector is no different than any other. It has a direction and magnitude; the only difference from what you are used to is maybe that its direction and magnitude change with t (time).

For (2d) vectors v = ai + bj, |v| = √(a2 + b2). Sometimes it is more convenient to use the dot product: v.v = a2 + b2, |v| = √(v.v)

Sometimes it's not always taught where this length integral comes from. You should notice that if r(t) is a position vector, then r'(t) is velocity, which makes speed |r'(t)|. Since distance = rate * time, the distance traveled in time dt is |r'(t)| dt. Add up the distances traveled during the entire time interval and you get the distance travelled.
 
  • #12
aralbrec said:
That looks right. I would have kept the exponential factored out to make it easier to take the magnitude.
Yes and take square root. This vector is no different than any other. It has a direction and magnitude; the only difference from what you are used to is maybe that its direction and magnitude change with t (time).

For (2d) vectors v = ai + bj, |v| = √(a2 + b2). Sometimes it is more convenient to use the dot product: v.v = a2 + b2, |v| = √(v.v)

Sometimes it's not always taught where this length integral comes from. You should notice that if r(t) is a position vector, then r'(t) is velocity, which makes speed |r'(t)|. Since distance = rate * time, the distance traveled in time dt is |r'(t)| dt. Add up the distances traveled during the entire time interval and you get the distance travelled.

Okay, I took the derivative of all the components and my length formula turned out to look like this:

L = ∫\stackrel{2\pi}{0} √(4e-4t + e-4tsin2t + 4e-4tcos2t + e-4tcos2t + 4e-4tsin2t)

= e-2t√( 4 + 5(cos2t + sin2t )
= e-2t√(4+5)
= 3e-2t

Using the fundamental theorem of calc, I got the answer to be 3e-4π - 3 ? Would this be the right answer?
 
  • #13
monnapomona said:
Oh yeah! okay hopefully this is right:

r'(t) = -2e-2t i - 2e-2tsin(t)+e-2tcos(t) j - e-2tsin(t) - 2e-2tcos(t) k

i'm a little confused on how to do length...
Could I square each vector like (i, j, k) and just add what I get for it together?
You really need extra parentheses:
r'(t) = -2e-2t i + (- 2e-2tsin(t)+e-2tcos(t) ) j + (- e-2tsin(t) - 2e-2tcos(t) )k

Then, in you last post it appears that your integration isn't quite right.
 
  • #14
SammyS said:
You really need extra parentheses:
r'(t) = -2e-2t i + (- 2e-2tsin(t)+e-2tcos(t) ) j + (- e-2tsin(t) - 2e-2tcos(t) )k

Then, in you last post it appears that your integration isn't quite right.

Oh wow, I forgot to integrate it... I got this as the answer:

\inte-2t = -1/2 e-2t

so -3/2(e^(-2t)) | ^{2π}_{0}

= -3/2(e-4π + 1)
 
  • #15
monnapomona said:
Oh wow, I forgot to integrate it... I got this as the answer:

\inte-2t = -1/2 e-2t

so -3/2(e^(-2t)) | ^{2π}_{0}

= -3/2(e-4π + 1)

Almost ...

It's -3/2(e-4π - 1)
 
  • #16
SammyS said:
Almost ...

It's -3/2(e-4π - 1)

Oh I see where I went wrong.

Thank you for all your help!
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
3K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
3K