Linear operators, quantum mechanics

12 replies · 3K views · last reply
cookiemnstr510510
Messages
162
Reaction score
14
Homework Statement
Show that two of the operators are linear and one is not
Relevant Equations
A(f+g)=Af+Ag
Hello,
I am struggling with what each piece of these equations are. I generally know the two rules that need to hold for an operator to be linear, but I am struggling with what each piece of each equation is/means.
Lets look at one of the three operators in question.
A(f(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)
I need to get an understanding of what each piece of the above equation says. Correct me when I am wrong.
A is the operator, but this also says that f(x) is the operator? does the partial derivative represent a partial derivative of our operator? If that is true our operator A is now equal to the partial derivative of our operator + 3 times our operator?

To show linearity we need to show A(f(x)+g(x)) is true and the scalar property, but let's first stick with this first one.

So I am already confused because we have an f(x) in the problem and our linearity rules have another f(x).

Here is my attempt at a solution, but it is practically worthless because I do not get what each piece means:

A(f(x)+g(x))=[(∂f/∂x)(f(x)+g(x))]+[3f(x)(f(x)+g(x))]
"= (∂f/∂x)*f(x) + (∂f/∂x)*g(x) + 3f(x)*f(x)+ 3f(x)*g(x)
"=A*f(x) + A*g(x) Not sure if this is right, not sure what A represents...
Any help would be appreciated, I think I am close, but I am not able to make sense of each variable.
I have searched far and wide online, but can't make sense of the info out there, too many elementary steps are skipped.
Any help would be appreciated!

Thank you.
 
cookiemnstr510510 said:
Homework Statement:: Show that two of the operators are linear and one is not
Homework Equations:: A(f+g)=Af+Ag

Hello,
I am struggling with what each piece of these equations are. I generally know the two rules that need to hold for an operator to be linear, but I am struggling with what each piece of each equation is/means.
Lets look at one of the three operators in question.
A(f(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)
I need to get an understanding of what each piece of the above equation says. Correct me when I am wrong.
A is the operator, but this also says that f(x) is the operator? does the partial derivative represent a partial derivative of our operator? If that is true our operator A is now equal to the partial derivative of our operator + 3 times our operator?

To show linearity we need to show A(f(x)+g(x)) is true and the scalar property, but let's first stick with this first one.

So I am already confused because we have an f(x) in the problem and our linearity rules have another f(x).

Here is my attempt at a solution, but it is practically worthless because I do not get what each piece means:

A(f(x)+g(x))=[(∂f/∂x)(f(x)+g(x))]+[3f(x)(f(x)+g(x))]
A is the operator that acts on a function. The result of applying the operator A on a function is to take the derivative of the function and add to the result three times the function.
Now, what you wrote as the action on f(x) + g(x) is incorrect. It should be

A(f(x)+g(x))=(∂f/∂x+∂g/∂x)+3(f(x)+g(x))
 
nrqed said:
A is the operator that acts on a function. The result of applying the operator A on a function is to take the derivative of the function and add to the result three times the function.
Now, what you wrote as the action on f(x) + g(x) is incorrect. It should be

A(f(x)+g(x))=(∂f/∂x+∂g/∂x)+3(f(x)+g(x))
Do you mean the result of A on a function is to take the partial derivative of the function?
 
nrqed said:
A is the operator that acts on a function. The result of applying the operator A on a function is to take the derivative of the function and add to the result three times the function.
Now, what you wrote as the action on f(x) + g(x) is incorrect. It should be

A(f(x)+g(x))=(∂f/∂x+∂g/∂x)+3(f(x)+g(x))
I think I get it, so our initial equation: A(f(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x) is defining what the operator A does. And what it is telling us is that A, the operator, takes a function and does two things to it:
1. it takes the partial derivative of the function, and
2. adds to it 3 times the initial function.
If that is it that makes sense to me.
 
Okay so here is my new attempt at the whole problem:
Complete question attached.
The two properties I need to fulfill are:
A(f(x)+g(x))=A(f(x))+A(g(x))
A(cf(x))=cA(f(x))

first example:
A(f(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)
A(f(x)+g(x))=(∂f/∂x)+(∂g/∂x)+3f(x)+3g(x)
A(f(x))+A(g(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)+(∂g/∂x)+3g(x) to me the RHS of this equation looks like LHS (just in different form)

A(f(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)
A(cf(x))=c*(∂f/∂x)+c*3f(x)
cA(f(x))=c[(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)] LHS=RHS, Linear

Next example:
B(f(x))=(1/2)f(x)(∂f/∂x)
B(f(x)+g(x))=(1/2)f(x)(∂f/∂x)+(1/2)g(x)(∂g/∂x)
B(f(x))+B(g(x))=(1/2)f(x)(∂f/∂x)+(1/2)g(x)(∂g/∂x) LHS=RHS, Linear

B(f(x))=(1/2)f(x)(∂f/∂x)
B(cf(x))=c(1/2)f(x)(∂f/∂x)
c*B(f(x))=c[(1/2)f(x)(∂f/∂x)] LHS=RHS, Linear

Last example attached.
I immediately see a problem with it. What I say this operator saying is this: The operator C takes a function f(x) in and outputs the definite integral from 0-->5 ∫(x-y)^3 f(y)dy. I don't understand how we could even set up the properties to see if linear? what is the f(y) doing in the integral, what is f(y) and why are integrating W.R.T y?
I am assuming this one is not linear, but could someone show me why? I don't see how I could go about showing this.
Thanks!
 
Attachments
Last edited:
cookiemnstr510510 said:
I think I get it, so our initial equation: A(f(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x) is defining what the operator A does. And what it is telling us is that A, the operator, takes a function and does two things to it:
1. it takes the partial derivative of the function, and
2. adds to it 3 times the initial function.
If that is it that makes sense to me.
Yes, exactly.

Note that I skipped a step when I wrote the effect of A on g+f. To be really detailed, one shoudl write

A[f(x)+g(x)]=(∂(f(x)+g(x))/∂x)+3(f(x)+g(x))

Using the fact that taking the derivative of a sum is the sum of the derivatives, one gets what I wrote earlier:

∂f(x)/∂x+∂g(x)/∂x +3(f(x)+g(x))

which is of course

∂f(x)/∂x+∂g(x)/∂x +3f(x)+3g(x)

Which is A(f(x))+ A(g(x))
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: cookiemnstr510510
nrqed said:
Yes, exactly.

Note that I skipped a step when I wrote the effect of A on g+f. To be really detailed, one shoudl write

A[f(x)+g(x)]=(∂(f(x)+g(x))/∂x)+3(f(x)+g(x))

Using the fact that taking the derivative of a sum is the sum of the derivatives, one gets what I wrote earlier:

∂f(x)/∂x+∂g(x)/∂x +3(f(x)+g(x))

which is of course

∂f(x)/∂x+∂g(x)/∂x +3f(x)+3g(x)

Which is A(f(x))+ A(g(x))
Oh wow, okay so I was wrong again! thank you.
So since our initial operator, A, takes a function and takes the partial derivative of it first. So for sum of two functions (f(x)+g(x)) we are taking the partial derivative of this entire quantity, not each individual part. so it would then look like your answer: (∂(f(x)+g(x))/∂x)
 
cookiemnstr510510 said:
Okay so here is my new attempt at the whole problem:
Complete question attached.
The two properties I need to fulfill are:
A(f(x)+g(x))=A(f(x))+A(g(x))
A(cf(x))=cA(f(x))

first example:
A(f(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)
A(f(x)+g(x))=(∂f/∂x)+(∂g/∂x)+3f(x)+3g(x)
A(f(x))+A(g(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)+(∂g/∂x)+3g(x) to me the RHS of this equation looks like LHS (just in different form)

A(f(x))=(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)
A(cf(x))=c*(∂f/∂x)+c*3f(x)
cA(f(x))=c[(∂f/∂x)+3f(x)] LHS=RHS, Linear

Your conclusion is correct. Although it is confusing when you write LHS=RHS, but I guess you mean the LHS and RHS of the equations near the top, in which case you are 100% correct.

Next example:
B(f(x))=(1/2)f(x)(∂f/∂x)
B(f(x)+g(x))=(1/2)f(x)(∂f/∂x)+(1/2)g(x)(∂g/∂x)
No, to get B(f(x)+g(x)), you must simply take the expression for B(f(x)) and replace every instance of f(x) by f(x)+g(x), which is not what you did.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: cookiemnstr510510
cookiemnstr510510 said:
Oh wow, okay so I was wrong again! thank you.
So since our initial operator, A, takes a function and takes the partial derivative of it first. So for sum of two functions (f(x)+g(x)) we are taking the partial derivative of this entire quantity, not each individual part. so it would then look like your answer: (∂(f(x)+g(x))/∂x)

You have some serious misconceptions that you need to iron out. To take your example:

##A(f(x)) = f(x)\frac{df}{dx}##

Now, if you want to operate on ##f(x) + g(x)##, a trick to see how to do this is first to let ##h(x) = f(x) + g(x)## and now:

##A(f(x) + g(x)) = A(h(x)) = h(x)\frac{dh}{dx} = (f(x) + g(x))\frac{d}{dx}(f(x) + g(x)##

In addition to clearing up why the operation works like it does, it also highlights the point that a function is a function and you cannot treat it any differently just because you write it as a sum. For example, we have:

##\cos (2x) = \cos^2 x - \sin^2 x = 2\cos^2 x - 1 = 1 - 2\sin^2 x##

If an operator acts on the function ##\cos 2x##, it cannot operate differently on these other variations. You can't come out with a different answer for ##A(\cos(2x))## just because you write it as ##A(\cos^2 x - \sin^2 x)##

cookiemnstr510510 said:
Last example attached.
I immediately see a problem with it. What I say this operator saying is this: The operator C takes a function f(x) in and outputs the definite integral from 0-->5 ∫(x-y)^3 f(y)dy. I don't understand how we could even set up the properties to see if linear? what is the f(y) doing in the integral, what is f(y) and why are integrating W.R.T y?
I am assuming this one is not linear, but could someone show me why? I don't see how I could go about showing this.
Thanks!

Note that a definite integral turns a function into a number. For example:

##\int_0^{\pi} \sin x \ dx = 2##

Simlarly, if you take a function of two variables, ##f(x, y)## and integrate with respect to one variable, then you get a function of the other. E.g.

##\int_0^1 xy \ dx = [\frac 1 2 yx^2]_0^1 = \frac y 2##

This allows you to define an operator by taking a function and integrating it in some way. To take your example$$C(f(x)) = \int_0^5 (x-y)^3f(y) \ dy$$
The RHS is a function of ##x##, as the ##y## variable gets integrated out, as it were. So, ##C## takes a function of ##x## and spits out a function of ##x##. ##C##, therefore, is an operator.

To see whether ##C## is linear or not, you need to think about the properties of the integral. Hint: a definite integral is generally a linear "thing"!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: cookiemnstr510510 and S.G. Janssens
PeroK said:
Note that a definite integral turns a function into a number. For example:

##\int_0^{\pi} \sin x \ dx = 2##

Simlarly, if you take a function of two variables, ##f(x, y)## and integrate with respect to one variable, then you get a function of the other. E.g.

##\int_0^1 xy \ dx = [\frac 1 2 yx^2]_0^1 = \frac y 2##

This allows you to define an operator by taking a function and integrating it in some way. To take your example$$C(f(x)) = \int_0^5 (x-y)^3f(y) \ dy$$
The RHS is a function of ##x##, as the ##y## variable gets integrated out, as it were. So, ##C## takes a function of ##x## and spits out a function of ##x##. ##C##, therefore, is an operator.

To see whether ##C## is linear or not, you need to think about the properties of the integral. Hint: a definite integral is generally a linear "thing"!

Physicists may find the following pedantic, but it can be very helpful to distinguish between the function ##f## and the value ##f(x)## of that function at the point ##x## in its domain. So, suppose you consider functions as vectors in some otherwise unspecified vector space ##V##. Then the operator ##C## defined in the quote above is defined as
$$
C : V \to V, \qquad (Cf)(x) = \int_0^5 (x - y)^3 f(y)\,dy.
$$
That is, ##C## takes the function ##f \in V## and maps it to ##Cf##, and we tell what ##Cf## is by specifying the value ##(Cf)(x)## at any point of the domain of ##Cf##.

To see if ##C## is linear, check whether ##C(f + g) = Cf + Cg## and ##C(a \cdot f) = a \cdot Cf##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PeroK
Yes, I nearly added that myself, but I thought I'd said enough already. Not pedantic at all, IMO.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: S.G. Janssens
PeroK said:
You have some serious misconceptions that you need to iron out. To take your example:

##A(f(x)) = f(x)\frac{df}{dx}##

Now, if you want to operate on ##f(x) + g(x)##, a trick to see how to do this is first to let ##h(x) = f(x) + g(x)## and now:

##A(f(x) + g(x)) = A(h(x)) = h(x)\frac{dh}{dx} = (f(x) + g(x))\frac{d}{dx}(f(x) + g(x)##

First, thank you for your response. Although I am still a bit confused, I am making some sort of progress.
Let me stick with the example quoted and go a bit further with it.
So my initial operator A is acting on some function f(x) and when it acts on that function it gives us ##f(x)\frac{df}{dx}##.

So our operator is acting on a function f. If I wanted to show that this operator was either linear or not I would use my two linearity properties (addition and scalar multiplication). To show addition I would need my operator to act on not only one function f(x) but on f(x)+g(x)--> ##A(f(x) + g(x))##
I like your idea about letting h(x)=f(x)+g(x).
So initially my operator turns a function f(x) into itself times its derivative, ##f(x)\frac{df}{dx}##.
So whatever my operator is acting on it will do those two things.
In the case of ##A(f(x) + g(x))## A has to spit out the thing inside of it, or f(x)+g(x) and the derivative of the thing inside of it which is ##\frac{d}{dx}(f(x) + g(x)##

For linearity we want A(f(x)+g(x))=A(f(x))+A(g(x))
In our case this operator would not be linear, because we are multiplying two sums like (a+b)(c+d)?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PeroK
cookiemnstr510510 said:
First, thank you for your response. Although I am still a bit confused, I am making some sort of progress.
Let me stick with the example quoted and go a bit further with it.
So my initial operator A is acting on some function f(x) and when it acts on that function it gives us ##f(x)\frac{df}{dx}##.

So our operator is acting on a function f. If I wanted to show that this operator was either linear or not I would use my two linearity properties (addition and scalar multiplication). To show addition I would need my operator to act on not only one function f(x) but on f(x)+g(x)--> ##A(f(x) + g(x))##
I like your idea about letting h(x)=f(x)+g(x).
So initially my operator turns a function f(x) into itself times its derivative, ##f(x)\frac{df}{dx}##.
So whatever my operator is acting on it will do those two things.
In the case of ##A(f(x) + g(x))## A has to spit out the thing inside of it, or f(x)+g(x) and the derivative of the thing inside of it which is ##\frac{d}{dx}(f(x) + g(x)##

For linearity we want A(f(x)+g(x))=A(f(x))+A(g(x))
In our case this operator would not be linear, because we are multiplying two sums like (a+b)(c+d)?

Yes, that the operator that is not linear. Technically, to show something is not linear you need a counterexample. In this case:

##A(f(x) + g(x)) = (f(x) + g(x))(f'(x) + g'(x))##

## \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ = f(x)f'(x) + g(x)g'(x) + [f(x)g'(x) + g(x)f'(x)]##

## \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ = A(f(x)) + A(g(x)) + [f(x)g'(x) + g(x)f'(x)]##

And, because that last expression in the square bracket is not always zero, then we see that ##A## is not linear.