Physics M.S in Physics with thesis vs without

  • Thread starter Thread starter Aaron M
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Physics Thesis
AI Thread Summary
Choosing between a thesis and a non-thesis M.S. program in physics involves weighing the prestige and research experience of a thesis against the structured, varied work of a dissertation. A thesis typically signifies an original contribution to the field, enhancing opportunities for publication and potentially benefiting those considering a Ph.D. However, the non-thesis option may offer more freedom in specialization and a less intense workload. It's crucial to understand the specific definitions and requirements of these terms at your institution, as they can vary significantly. Ultimately, selecting a program that aligns with your career goals and interests is essential, as graduate work is significantly more demanding than undergraduate studies.
Aaron M
Messages
24
Reaction score
4
I am on the last stretch of my B.S in Physics. I have been accepted into graduate school at my university, however they have two M.S programs in physics, one with a thesis and one without. I expect the more traditional route would be the thesis program but I am uncertain of the advantages and disadvantages between the two. I am unsure if I will continue with my education into my Ph.D or go straight into industry. At the moment I am currently 50/50 between the two.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The one without is usually a dissertation masters ... a thesis means that you will have a record of an original contribution to the field so it usually carries more prestige. You'll also be one up on those BS(hons) and year-1 PhD students. There is usually more of a chance to publish too ... however, a dissertation can be more structured, have more varied work (thesis work can get very ocd inducing), and you can get more freedom in what you specialise on. All this depends on the college.

Whichever you choose - the work is a whole order of magnitude tougher than the bachelors ever was ... you will have no life: so pick something you are likely to enjoy.

Bottom line you need to look carefully at what is involved in each course and if you can change half-way through. Talk to the MS people in your college.
 
  • Like
Likes Logical Dog
Simon Bridge said:
The one without is usually a dissertation masters ... a thesis means that you will have a record of an original contribution to the field so it usually carries more prestige. You'll also be one up on those BS(hons) and year-1 PhD students. There is usually more of a chance to publish too ... however, a dissertation can be more structured, have more varied work (thesis work can get very ocd inducing), and you can get more freedom in what you specialise on. All this depends on the college.

Whichever you choose - the work is a whole order of magnitude tougher than the bachelors ever was ... you will have no life: so pick something you are likely to enjoy.

Bottom line you need to look carefully at what is involved in each course and if you can change half-way through. Talk to the MS people in your college.

Thank you for the excellent advice!
 
(a) A word of caution here. Terms such as "thesis" and "dissertation" mean different things (sometimes opposite), depending on the country, and, even within the same country, on the college or university. When I got my bachelor's in physics (in the US) many moons ago, I was required to complete a thesis, which, at my school, meant an original research project. That was a rarity. Recently, I talked to a student who was required to complete a thesis for her bachelor's thesis in physics at a small US college. I was surprised. But turned out that her "thesis" was essentially a term paper, in which she read texts and research papers in depth, and then wrote a summary paper.

So, if your "thesis" requires original research, there can be value, since you get actual research experience, which can be valuable in determining whether you want to go for a PhD and which can be valuable as experience listed on a resume, in case you decide not to pursue a PhD: you learn a lot more doing actual research, rather than just taking courses. But if the "thesis" is essentially a term paper, I wouldn't bother.

(b) That said, in the US, a MS Physics doesn't amount to much. A MS in EE, ME, or CS can prepare you for a career as a lead design engineer. But if you want a career as a principal in physics-related R&D, you will typically need a PhD in physics (there are always exceptions). In my grad school, we got the MS simply upon satisfactory passing of 1 yr of required grad courses. It was really a consolation prize for students who failed to pass their qualifying exam (this term also varies by country and university; at my school, it was a comprehensive written exam based on the required first yr grad courses. You were given two shots at it.)
 
I don't know if anyone on here works for any of the well known defense companies of your country, whichever country you are from?? Also, if you choose to work in one, do you think the engineering education provide from your school would adequately prepare you for the job. What do I mean by that? Well if you work at say Lockheed Martin and you work in the latest iteration of a missile or if you work at Pratt & Whitney, they assign you to work in the team helping out with building the jet...
Hello, I graduated from undergrad a few years ago with a Major in Physics and minor in Electrical Engineering. I tried to get experience working on and testing circuits through my professor who studied Neutrinos, however covid caused the opportunity to go away and I graduated with no experience or internships. I have attempted to break into the engineering industry with no success. Right now I am considering going for a Masters in Electrical Engineering and I need advice on if this would be...
So lately, my interest in the realm of optics/optoelectronics/photonics engineering has grown and I have started to seriously consider pursuing a career in the field. I have done a bit of career research and also have done some learning on the side to gather more knowledge on these topics. However, I have some questions on what a career in these fields would look like, and I wanted to find out more about this area to know what I would be getting myself into if I did make the choice to pursue...

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
493
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top