Magnetic flux through a triangular loop?

6 replies · 7K views · last reply
Abdulwahab Hajar
Messages
56
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


Determine the mutual inductance between a very long, straight wire and a conducting equilateral triangular loop

Homework Equations


I know how to do it but I'm stuck at the step of finding the total inductance through the triange.

The Attempt at a Solution


we know that the magnetic field due to an infinitely long wire is
B = µI/2πr
in order to find the magnetic flux through the triangle we need to find Φ = ∫B.dA
we have B but what would dA be in this case
the book says it's (2/√3) * (r - d) *dr
why is that so?

thank you
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a straight vertical wire on the left with an equilateral triangular loop to its right, the triangle's vertex pointing toward the wire, and the distance from the wire to the vertex labeled d and the triangle's side labeled b.
    q.png
    362 bytes · Views: 1,130
Look at the geometry for your triangle.
Starting at the point closest to the wire, we will call that ##(d, 0)## , you will follow a counterclockwise path to ##(d+\frac{b\sqrt{3}}{2}, -\frac b2 )##, then from
##(d+\frac{b\sqrt{3}}{2}, -\frac b2 )## to ##(d+\frac{b\sqrt{3}}{2}, +\frac b2 )##, and finally from ##(d+\frac{b\sqrt{3}}{2}, +\frac b2 )## to ##(d,0 )##.
Of course, you can parameterize each of those line integrals to get a form that is easier to work with.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Abdulwahab Hajar
RUber said:
Look at the geometry for your triangle.
Starting at the point closest to the wire, we will call that ##(d, 0)## , you will follow a counterclockwise path to ##(d+\frac{b\sqrt{3}}{2}, -\frac b2 )##, then from
##(d+\frac{b\sqrt{3}}{2}, -\frac b2 )## to ##(d+\frac{b\sqrt{3}}{2}, +\frac b2 )##, and finally from ##(d+\frac{b\sqrt{3}}{2}, +\frac b2 )## to ##(d,0 )##.
Of course, you can parameterize each of those line integrals to get a form that is easier to work with.
Ok that really helped to be honest.
Thank you sir
But that would be a line integral right?
what if I wanted to cover the surface as in the area covered by the sides of the triangle
 
Then, in that case, you would have x going from d to d+b/2 * sqrt(3) and y ranging from the lower line to the upper line (as a function of x).
These bounds are no fun to work with, but will get you to the answer for the surface integral.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Abdulwahab Hajar
RUber said:
Then, in that case, you would have x going from d to d+b/2 * sqrt(3) and y ranging from the lower line to the upper line (as a function of x).
These bounds are no fun to work with, but will get you to the answer for the surface integral.
Yeah I get ya...
is there anyway to do it with a change in r since it covers both x and y directions...
this is how it is in the solution manual perhaps if you take a look you could understand how it was derived
I just couldn't figure it out
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation of mutual inductance L12 for a long straight wire, problem P.5-16, with integrals of B dot ds over a triangular loop in r and d, ending with L12 = (mu0/pi)[b/2 - (d/sqrt3) ln(1 + sqrt3 b/(2d))].
    q.png
    17 KB · Views: 907
I see what they did there. Since the wire in infinitely long, B is only dependent on r, the distance from the line.
So, if you slice up the equilateral triangle vertically, along lines with the same distance to the wire, you get
##\int\int B \, dA = \int B h(r) dr, ##
where ##h(r)## is the height of the triangle at distance r.
At r=d, the height is 0, and at r = ##d+b\sqrt{3}/2##, the height is b. So you can make a linear rule for the height that looks like
## h = (r-d)\frac{2}{\sqrt{3}} .##
Check that against the reference points to make sure.
So, now you can treat the integral in terms of one variable, r.
##\int B h(r) dr = \int B (r-d)\frac{2}{\sqrt{3}}\, dr ##
The final answer applies a simplification in the natural log, but otherwise, you should be able to follow the rest from there with about 2 extra steps.
I hope this helps.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Abdulwahab Hajar
RUber said:
I see what they did there. Since the wire in infinitely long, B is only dependent on r, the distance from the line.
So, if you slice up the equilateral triangle vertically, along lines with the same distance to the wire, you get
##\int\int B \, dA = \int B h(r) dr, ##
where ##h(r)## is the height of the triangle at distance r.
At r=d, the height is 0, and at r = ##d+b\sqrt{3}/2##, the height is b. So you can make a linear rule for the height that looks like
## h = (r-d)\frac{2}{\sqrt{3}} .##
Check that against the reference points to make sure.
So, now you can treat the integral in terms of one variable, r.
##\int B h(r) dr = \int B (r-d)\frac{2}{\sqrt{3}}\, dr ##
The final answer applies a simplification in the natural log, but otherwise, you should be able to follow the rest from there with about 2 extra steps.
I hope this helps.
It's great man
Thanks a lot
You're the best