Magnetic Force on Iron

  • #1
685
16
I searched different places but couldn't find how actually you calculate this:-
What is the magnitude of force experienced by a cylindrical piece of iron placed near the end of a solenoid with internal field strength B0.
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Vanadium 50
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
2021 Award
27,691
11,972
The reason you keep asking this and not getting an answer is that the force is not dependent on the field strength. It's dependent on the gradient of the field strength. This is zero for an ideal (long) solenoid and complicated for a real one.
 
  • #3
685
16
It's dependent on the gradient of the field strength.
Ok, then how do i calculate the force if I know the gradient of the field i.e. I know the function B(x,y,z).
 
  • #4
4,662
6
Ok, then how do i calculate the force if I know the gradient of the field i.e. I know the function B(x,y,z).
One way to calculate the force is to examine how the total stored magnetic energy W of the system changes if the iron object is displaced by a distance dx. As you know, work (energy) is force F times distance dx. So the derivative of the stored energy W in the direction dx is the force in the direction dx:

Fx = dW/dx.

Smythe's (Static and Dynamic Electricity) exact solution for the axial field of a finite length solenoid is given in post #4 (see thumbnail) of this thread:
https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=352947

Bob S
 
Last edited:
  • #5
685
16
Thanks for that. It really helped me.

One way to calculate the force is to examine how the total stored magnetic energy W of the system changes if the iron object is displaced by a distance dx. As you know, work (energy) is force F times distance dx. So the derivative of the stored energy W in the direction dx is the force in the direction dx:
Fx = dW/dx.
So can I proceed like this to calculate the force on a small iron piece lying some distance from the axis of the solenoid.?
1. The B inside the iron is multiplied by factor ur, So Biron=urBu0
2.The total Energy stored inside the piece can be calculated by intergrating over the entire volume of the iron piece
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/%E2%80%8Chbase/electric/imgele/engbf.gif [Broken]
3. When the iron piece is moved a small distance then then the total Energy Stored will change.

Then applying Fx = dW/dx. will give the force.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #6
4,662
6
I believe the magnetic energy density outside the iron is

(1/2μ0)∫B2 dV

and inside the iron it is

(1/2μμ0)∫B2 dV

so because B is continuous there is very little energy stored inside the iron.

But there is a dipole field outside the iron that I have not included.

I know there is a thread on this but I cannot find it.

Bob S
 
  • #7
685
16
Inside the iron it is
(1/2μμ0)∫B2 dV
so because B is continuous there is very little energy stored inside the iron.
on the contrarary I think there is lot of energy inside the iron because
the total energy inside iron, as you pointed out, is
(1/2μμ0)∫B2 dV
But, B = μB0
So, the energy stored becomes
(1/2μμ0)∫(Bμ)2 dV
= (1/2μμ02∫B2 dV
= (μ/2μ0)∫B2 dV

When the piece of iron is moved a small distance towards the solenoid, the intensity of B increases, so does the energy stored inside the iron.
So, the iron shouldn't move towards the solenoid (since it creates increased energy).
This is directly against the fact that the iron piece is attracted towards the solenoid!!!??
 
Last edited:
  • #8
4,662
6
on the contrarary I think there is lot of energy inside the iron because
the total energy inside iron, as you pointed out, is
(1/2μμ0)∫B2 dV
But, B = μB0
So, the energy stored becomes
(1/2μμ0)∫(Bμ)2 dV
= (1/2μμ02∫B2 dV
= (μ/2μ0)∫B2 dV

When the piece of iron is moved a small distance towards the solenoid, the intensity of B increases, so does the energy stored inside the iron.
So, the iron shouldn't move towards the solenoid (since it creates increased energy).
This is directly against the fact that the iron piece is attracted towards the solenoid!!!??
Err..... no. Very little energy is stored in the iron. Because the normal component of B is continuous, the energy density is higher in the air than in the iron. See thumbnail.
Bob S
 

Attachments

  • Magnet_air_gap.jpg
    Magnet_air_gap.jpg
    38.8 KB · Views: 2,056
Last edited:
  • #9
685
16
Err..... no. Very little energy is stored in the iron. Because the normal component of B is continuous, the energy density is higher in the air than in the iron.
Bob S
But In wikipaedia I read this:
f0d14e04603d965b4d625a59745dae55.png

(here u is the total energy stored).
I am confused that, Is it B or H , that is same for both air core and iron-core solenoid?
 
  • #10
4,662
6
The basic form for the energy stored in a magnetic field is

W = (1/2)∫ B H dV

In a magnetic system that has both iron and air in the same flux, only B (the normal component) is continuous at the air / iron interface. So we write

W = (1/2μrμ0)∫ B2 dV in iron, and

W = (1/2μ0)∫ B2 dV in air

Bob S
 

Related Threads on Magnetic Force on Iron

Replies
1
Views
557
Replies
10
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
7K
Replies
2
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
9K
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
32
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Top