Magnetic Force: Questions & Experiments

AI Thread Summary
Magnetic force is generally perpendicular to the surface of a magnet, and altering the shape of a magnet does not allow for the direction of the magnetic field to be easily redirected. Cutting a magnetic rod at an angle or making it uneven does not create a neutral point; each segment will still have a north and south pole. The shape of the magnet can influence the magnetic field to some extent, particularly in designed applications like electric motors, but simple alterations won't significantly change the field's direction. For custom-sized soft iron rods, larger sizes may not be available due to manufacturing limitations rather than magnetic efficiency. Understanding the complexities of magnetic polarization and field shaping requires further research into magnetic field design principles.
_Bd_
Messages
107
Reaction score
0
Hi, I am trying to play around with magnets on my free time, I ordered some neodyum magnets and I've been thinking of making my own electromagnets, I had some of questions and I was hoping someone here mmight help me:



1. About magnetic force:
AFAIK magnetic force is perpendicula to the surface it is emitted from right? but my question is, if I cut an angle in a magnetic rod (say at 45 deg), will I be able to exert a force at 45 degrees?


How does magnetic polarization work with unevenly shaped magnets:

if I cut a magnetic rod and make it pointy on one side (but not the other), it would loose its symmetry, where would the "mid-point" be? (where the polarity changes) or will it loose its magnetism just for being uneven?
I would assume it would be in the center of mass (thats just my assumption, but I would like to get this confirmed)

Here's the project I have in mind (its a really simple sketch but I hope it gets the idea across):

http://imageshack.us/a/img22/493/weirdexperiment.png



======== not so important question ============

2. Where can I get some "custom sized" soft-iron rods?, TBH I've searched the internet and they only come in like super small sizes
2.a. are they only sold in small sizes because bigger sizes are not "magnetically efficient" ?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
In a nutshell. No.

A magnet is actually not a single thing, it is a collection of magnetic particles all roughly lined up with each other. The general result of that is a magnetic field that appears to come from a point somewhere inside the magnet near one end (the north pole) and circles round to vanish back inside to a point near the other (the south pole)

Whatever shape the surface is has pretty well nothing to do with it.
 
1) The shape of the end has little effect on the direction of the magnetic field. Consider the relative size of the space around the end and the tip size itelf.

2) There is no such point as a neutral point in a magnet. If you break a magnet at any point each part has a N pole at one end and an S pole at the other.

3) You need to reorder the numbering of your questions.

4) I suggest you look in a toolshop for screwdriver magnetiser/demagnetisers. They are very cheap and can perform their stuff on screwdriver shafts or other ferrous metal object.
 
Thank you for the replies

Studiot said:
1) The shape of the end has little effect on the direction of the magnetic field. Consider the relative size of the space around the end and the tip size itelf.

2) There is no such point as a neutral point in a magnet. If you break a magnet at any point each part has a N pole at one end and an S pole at the other.

3) You need to reorder the numbering of your questions.

4) I suggest you look in a toolshop for screwdriver magnetiser/demagnetisers. They are very cheap and can perform their stuff on screwdriver shafts or other ferrous metal object.
2) I know there is no such point as a neutral, but if you see a diagram of the magnetic field
Magnet0873.png

you can clearly see there is a "mid point" (mid not neutral)but again, take that same idea (as this picture), how would the magnetic force lines be affected by that shaped I drew?
as you can see all the magnetic force lines are somewhat perpendicular to the surface they are coming from, that's where my question arises from
 
_Bd_ said:
as you can see all the magnetic force lines are somewhat perpendicular to the surface they are coming from

Sorry, I don't see that.
 
ImaLooser said:
Sorry, I don't see that.

Nor do I. The metal surface just happens to be perpendicular to the field lines in a few places.

It IS possible to 'shape' a magnetic field by design of the shape of pole pieces. In electric motors for example, the pole pieces and armature are curved to create a radial field.
But you can't just alter the shape of a bar magnet and expect to 'shoot' magnetic field in some direction.
 
AJ Bentley, would you be so kind as to point me where to get information on "shaping" magnetic fields
 
Back
Top