Magnetic forces/fields don't do work?

  • #1
310
0
Now, I'm not sure if I misunderstood the text book but I read that magnetic fields and forces don't actually do any work. How is this the case? Consider a bar magnetic and some iron filings. If you use the magnet to attract the filings towards it wouldn't some sort of work be done? Thanks.
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
35,509
11,966
Now, I'm not sure if I misunderstood the text book but I read that magnetic fields and forces don't actually do any work.
That is a simplified description for static magnetic fields, with free charges moving in them. Your system does not have that.
 
  • #3
694
142
Well the magnetic force term definitely drops out when we calculate the work done on a small displacement, but that does not mean the magnetic field does not take part.
 
  • #5
102
0
Now, I'm not sure if I misunderstood the text book but I read that magnetic fields and forces don't actually do any work.
That's true for classical electrodynamics but not always the case in certain quantum mechanical situations. E.g. if you were to place a charged particle at rest in a non-uniform magnetic field then the magnetic field would do work on the charged particle because it has a magnetic moment and thus acts as a microscopic bar magnet.

How is this the case? Consider a bar magnetic and some iron filings. If you use the magnet to attract the filings towards it wouldn't some sort of work be done? Thanks.
Work is being done, just not by the magnetic field. It's the electric field of the charges which make up the iron fillings which are doing the work. This is all explained in the following two articles

Work done on a charged particles in magnetic fields, Charles A. Coombes, Am. J. Phys. 47(10), October 1979

Magnetic Forces doing work?, Eugene P. Mosca, Am. J. Phys.42, 295 (1974).

If you want to read these articles I can look into creating an e-mail account in order to send them to you with.
 
  • #6
310
0
Great stuff. Thanks for that. I'm not sure that I'll be doing much further reading on the subject at the moment. This is great for now.
 
  • #7
102
0
Great stuff. Thanks for that. I'm not sure that I'll be doing much further reading on the subject at the moment. This is great for now.
You're most welcome. I love the American Journal of Physics. It's my favorite physics journal because I love thinking about the foundations of physics.

I've gathered a considerable number of articles over the years and have scanned them all into my computer. I lost a lot of them due to a system crash so I'll have to start over and scan a lot of them in again. If you ever want to read something on a particular subject that is in that journal then let me know. I can obtain a copy and forward it to you. I wrote to the editor of that journal and was given permission to do so, so don't worry about copyrights. They said it was okay to disseminate an article for educational purposes.
 
  • #8
310
0
Brilliant. Thanks for that and I'll be sure to ask for those if I ever feel the need to read on.
 
  • #9
102
0
Brilliant. Thanks for that and I'll be sure to ask for those if I ever feel the need to read on.
You're most welcome. I finally realized that you can upload files into posts that can be read by anyone reasding the post. I greatly enjoy helping people learn physics and math in anyway that I'm able to. It just feels so good to do so. Ever notice that yourself? :tongue:
 

Related Threads on Magnetic forces/fields don't do work?

  • Last Post
Replies
17
Views
9K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
43
Views
8K
Replies
2
Views
745
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
4K
Replies
407
Views
54K
Replies
36
Views
1K
Replies
84
Views
33K
Replies
15
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Last Post
3
Replies
74
Views
10K
Top