Maxwell's Demon Possibility?(Entropy)

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the concept of Maxwell's Demon, a thought experiment proposed by James Clerk Maxwell that challenges the second law of thermodynamics by suggesting a mechanism to decrease entropy. The scenario involves two chambers of gas separated by a gate monitored by an intelligent entity that can sort molecules based on their speed, resulting in one chamber containing only slow molecules and the other only fast ones, thus creating a temperature difference. Participants explore the implications of this idea, questioning its feasibility and relevance to real-world applications. The Ranque-Hilsch vortex tube is mentioned as a practical example of a device that separates hot and cold air through airflow dynamics, hinting at potential connections to the theoretical concepts discussed. One contributor expresses interest in a personal idea related to vortex dynamics that may also address entropy, although they consider it underdeveloped.
StarkyDee
"Maxwell's Demon" Possibility?(Entropy)

About a hundred years ago, James Clerk Maxwell imagined 2 adjacent chambers, each containing gas and both sealed to the outside world. The chambers are also sealed from one another, except for a single gate the size of a gas molecule. Guarding this gate would be an intelligence with one power: the ability to discriminate between fast and slow molecules. It would pass slow molecules in one direction only, fast molecules in the other direction only. The net result would, after a time, be one chamber that contained only slow-moving molecules, next to a chamber that contained only fast-moving molecules. In other words, the chambers would not be the same temperature: One hot and one cold. Should such a "Maxwell Demon" prove possible, its discriminatory intelligence would reverse the apparently irreversible entropy, which inevitably has everything existing at the same low temperature? Any Comments?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Have you ever heard of the ranque-Hilsch vortex tube that separates hot and cold air? It operates simply by virtue of the air flow through the geometry of the device.

Click here for the thermodynamic aspects of the device.
http://engr.smu.edu/me/2131/Thermolab/vortex/vortex.html

Creator
 
Last edited:
I have thought about such things, and though the consensus is no, I have a half-baked idea oddly enough also involving a vortex that seems like it would decrease entropy. As it is half-baked I don't care to share it, but if you visit here often I will PM you with the idea, if it proves interesting.
 
This is from Griffiths' Electrodynamics, 3rd edition, page 352. I am trying to calculate the divergence of the Maxwell stress tensor. The tensor is given as ##T_{ij} =\epsilon_0 (E_iE_j-\frac 1 2 \delta_{ij} E^2)+\frac 1 {\mu_0}(B_iB_j-\frac 1 2 \delta_{ij} B^2)##. To make things easier, I just want to focus on the part with the electrical field, i.e. I want to find the divergence of ##E_{ij}=E_iE_j-\frac 1 2 \delta_{ij}E^2##. In matrix form, this tensor should look like this...
Thread 'Applying the Gauss (1835) formula for force between 2 parallel DC currents'
Please can anyone either:- (1) point me to a derivation of the perpendicular force (Fy) between two very long parallel wires carrying steady currents utilising the formula of Gauss for the force F along the line r between 2 charges? Or alternatively (2) point out where I have gone wrong in my method? I am having problems with calculating the direction and magnitude of the force as expected from modern (Biot-Savart-Maxwell-Lorentz) formula. Here is my method and results so far:- This...
Back
Top