Mechanics (the book is too expensive) - would *this* work?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the high cost of the required textbook for a senior-level engineering mechanics course, prompting the student to consider alternatives. The primary textbook, "Engineering Mechanics Statics & Dynamics" by Bedford and Fowler, costs $170, which the student finds excessive. They contemplate photocopying problem sets from a classmate and using "An Introduction to Mechanics" by Kleppner and Kolenkow as a supplementary resource. However, responses indicate that while Kleppner and Kolenkow is a solid physics text, it may not align well with the engineering focus of the required course. Suggestions include finding a cheaper used edition of the Bedford and Fowler text and utilizing free resources available online. Overall, the consensus leans towards acquiring the required text or a similar engineering-focused book to ensure proper alignment with course material.
FrogPad
Messages
801
Reaction score
0
I am in my senior year as an EE student. Part of the curriculum is a course in mechanics, particularly (from the course description):

Force systems, resultants, moments and equilibrium. Kinematics and kinetics of particles, systems of particles and rigid bodies. Energy and momentum principles. Lecture, recitation. Prerequisites: PHY 121, 122. Pre- or corequisite: preferably MAT 275 (or 274).

The required text is Engineering Mechanics Statics & Dynamics (Bedford, Fowler); this is where the homework problems will be taken from. The book costs 170.00. To me this is outrageous, and I refuse to pay this much for a book I will never keep.

I had this thought, that I shall simply photocopy the problem sets from a fellow classmate, and pick up some book to suppliment the information. After some browsing I have found, An Introduction To Mechanics (Keppner, Kolenkow) for a very reasonable price.

Does anyone recommend that A: I do this, and B: That the Keppner, Kolenkow book would be enough to suppliment the other book?


Thanks in advance,
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I'm not acquainted with your required text, but from the title I strongly suspect that it's oriented towards engineering methods and applications. Kleppner and Kolenkow, on the other hand, is very much a physicist's textbook, and I would expect it to be more "theoretical" than the other book. I would not expect it to mesh well with your course.
 
jtbell said:
I'm not acquainted with your required text, but from the title I strongly suspect that it's oriented towards engineering methods and applications. Kleppner and Kolenkow, on the other hand, is very much a physicist's textbook, and I would expect it to be more "theoretical" than the other book. I would not expect it to mesh well with your course.

To me Kleppner and Kolenkow looks like I would actually learn the material. The other text reminds me of a halliday resnick treatment of mechanics.

I found a statics and dynamics text available free through (I believe) Cambridge professors that I will try out.

Thank you for your response. I am very glad I asked before ordering.
 
Kleppner & Kolenkow is an honors freshman-physics textbook, so probably something like a PHY 121 textbook at your school. It is a book worth having, especially if you can get it for cheap, but it is not a sophomore-level engineering statics/dynamics textbook, and it probably will not be very helpful for taking such a course. (It would, however, be a great way to review freshman physics in preparation for this course. :smile: ) I would suggest picking up one of the $4 used copies of the previous edition of the Bedford & Fowler text and photocopying the problem sets--I did basically the same thing for my first two circuits courses as an EE undergrad. :smile:
 
where did you find Kleppner for a reasonable price? Amazon has it for 150 ...
 
Back
Top