My friends suck or I am too whiny?

  • Thread starter Thread starter johndude222
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Friends
Click For Summary
A university student expresses feelings of loneliness and depression, stemming from a lack of social interaction and one-sided friendships. He frequently helps his friends with academic work, but feels unappreciated, as they often neglect him outside of school-related tasks. Despite his efforts to be kind, he receives little acknowledgment, leading to frustration, especially after a disappointing birthday experience. The discussion highlights the importance of recognizing unhealthy relationships, with several participants suggesting that the student is being used rather than having genuine friendships. They encourage him to be more assertive and to seek out new social connections through clubs or activities that interest him. Many emphasize the need for self-care and professional help for his depression, advocating for a shift in focus from helping others to finding personal fulfillment and building meaningful relationships. The conversation underscores that true friendships should be reciprocal and supportive, not exploitative.
  • #31
Moonbear said:
Let's not try diagnosing people online. This is best saved for the health professionals.

I'm not diagnosing him. But if he suddenly realizes "Oh my God, that describes me." then something's up. That's how I realized I had depression. I read the symptoms online and it hit me like a ton of bricks.

If someone had told me I had depression before that, I would have just ignored them. It wasn't until I realized I wasn't alone with those feelings that I decided to get help and saw a counselor.

In this case, I see that he is having trouble connecting with others, which is something I have trouble with, too. I have several of those symptoms, so maybe we have something in common.

After all, everybody is telling him "Go make friends" as if you just went to Safeway and bought a 6-pack of them and I seem to be the only one saying that I actually understand what he means by saying it's hard for him to make friends.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
CaptainQuasar said:
I mean like johndude222 and myself. I have had experiences similar to him.

You can join the club too if you want in, Cyrus. But you have to learn the secret handshake and earn your decoder ring.


You guys don't have friends, but you have a club with secret handshakes and decoder rings? Who shows up to the club meetings? :biggrin:

*runs back to Cyrus' fort*
 
  • #33
Poop-Loops said:
I'm not diagnosing him. But if he suddenly realizes "Oh my God, that describes me." then something's up. That's how I realized I had depression. I read the symptoms online and it hit me like a ton of bricks.
He already told us he's depressed. We'll leave it to the professionals to determine if it's something that needs treatment or something that would be fixed by going out and doing something to make friends.

After all, everybody is telling him "Go make friends" as if you just went to Safeway and bought a 6-pack of them and I seem to be the only one saying that I actually understand what he means by saying it's hard for him to make friends.

Not really, we're telling him things he can do so that he increases his chances of meeting people who will become friends. You can't just walk up to people in the street and say, "Will you be my friend?" But, you can do things you enjoy and while you're doing them, friends will just happen, as long as you don't drive everyone away with negativity.
 
  • #34
CaptainQuasar said:
I mean like johndude222 and myself. I have had experiences similar to him.

You can join the club too if you want in, Cyrus. But you have to learn the secret handshake and earn your decoder ring.



I'm right there with you, CQ and johndude! One time, I helped a fellow student with a particularly tricky quantum homework problem. I asked him if he had solved one that I couldn't get - he said, no.

Come to find out that yes, he had solved it but didn't want to share it with me. The physics department I went to was SO freaking competitive. Dog eat dog...it wasn't pleasant at all.

I didn't make any friends in college. Work life, yes - many, many friends. So hang in there johndude! If you like helping people it shows that you are a good person!
 
  • #35
CaptainQuasar said:
Not to mention it would be kind of embarrassing to eventually explain to a professional. “Uh, yeah, so this guy named Poop-loops diagnosed me online…”


:smile:
 
  • #36
lisab said:
I'm right there with you, CQ and johndude! One time, I helped a fellow student with a particularly tricky quantum homework problem. I asked him if he had solved one that I couldn't get - he said, no.

Come to find out that yes, he had solved it but didn't want to share it with me. The physics department I went to was SO freaking competitive. Dog eat dog...it wasn't pleasant at all.

I didn't make any friends in college. Work life, yes - many, many friends. So hang in there johndude! If you like helping people it shows that you are a good person!

Yikes, I would have transferred out of there pronto!
 
  • #37
For the last time, I'm not diagnosing him. I just think it would be easier for him to go seek help if he knew that his symptoms were part of something bigger.

Like I said before, I had depression but refused to get help, because I thought my problems would go away or that they weren't real problem. I was afraid that if I went to get help, the doc would say "You're fine." or worse, think I was making it up. It wasn't until I found out that yes, I had some major problems that I decided to get help.
 
  • #38
Well, in my university, you can only be tutor if you have already taken a course..

I like helping people when I am taking the same course as them but tutoring someone on stuff I learned ages ago isn't something I like to do.

* Emotional coldness, detachment or reduced affection.

Not sure if I am cold or detached. I do feel sorry for other people and stuff.
* Limited capacity to express either positive or negative emotions towards others.
Yeah, one of the things I can never do is express my negative opinions towards others. I keep those to my self.
* Consistent preference for solitary activities.
Yeah, I hang out alone usually. Not by choice but I am quite poor and can't afford school residence. So I am force to live in some cheap place with poor heating and rather far from campus. I used to live with my mom in high school but now I live by myself.

* Very few (if any) close friends or relationships, and a lack of desire for such.
I do desire it, is just I don't have them. Trust me, I would do anything to have a close friend.

* Indifference to either praise or criticism.
If someone say thanks or say I am awesome or somethign like that when I help them, I am happy for the rest of the day.
* Taking pleasure in few, if any, activities.
Yeah that's probably true.
* Indifference to social norms and conventions.
Yeah, I don't know much about social norms and conventions. I came from a different country about 9 years ago.
* Preoccupation with fantasy and introspection.
Fantasy? Yeah, sometimes I dream myself as a big bad warrior and I used to play fantasy games.
* Lack of desire for sexual experiences with another person.
I am all for sex. At first I was rather disturbed by it but now sometimes I can't think about while I am bored. I never had sex though.
 
  • #39
I understand Poop-loops and it was a good idea to bring up some of the clinical symptoms of depression. I think what confused the rest of us is that you started posing questions instead of just saying, “by the way, here's a list of symptoms of clinical depression.”
 
  • #40
Cyrus said:
Yikes, I would have transferred out of there pronto!

I was just focused on graduating. I did get a GREAT education, which is what I went there for. I didn't go there to make friends.
 
  • #41
lisab said:
I'm right there with you, CQ and johndude! One time, I helped a fellow student with a particularly tricky quantum homework problem. I asked him if he had solved one that I couldn't get - he said, no.

Come to find out that yes, he had solved it but didn't want to share it with me. The physics department I went to was SO freaking competitive. Dog eat dog...it wasn't pleasant at all.

I didn't make any friends in college. Work life, yes - many, many friends. So hang in there johndude! If you like helping people it shows that you are a good person!

Cyrus said:
Yikes, I would have transferred out of there pronto!

Nah, just means you have to meet people outside your department. One place I worked, I had very little in common with any of my coworkers. They were either sports fanatics (beyond fans...everything they did seemed to revolve around sports...and folks know how NOT into sports I am) or they were married with kids and only did things that revolved around kid-friendly activities, or didn't go out at all because it was a hassle for them to get sitters. I so didn't fit in with them. But, that just meant work was for working, and I went elsewhere to play.

That's really the main point. If you're not making friends where you are, go someplace else and meet different people.
 
  • #42
Your "friends"=moochers
Anyways, I like the private tutor idea, you could even get some money like that.
 
  • #43
johndude222 said:
I am all for sex.

I'm all for sex too! What a coincidence. See, this club does have a lot in common.
 
  • #44
johndude222 said:
I came from a different country about 9 years ago.

Aha! Now we're getting information that might be helpful. Moving to a new country and adapting to a new culture can make it more challenging to make friends for a while.

Does your school have an international students association, or anything like that? Or what about a club for other students from your country of origin? You might find yourself more comfortable around people who have more in common with your cultural background, at least until you adjust better to American culture (then again 9 years isn't really a short time to be here...you've got to get out and experience the culture to learn to adapt to it).
 
  • #45
Yeah some of the people I helped offered me money but I refused. I don't help people for money. If they offer me money that's kinda bad cause now I have to make sure that I am tutoring their money's worth. I just help people cause I am bored and one of those big thank yous I get make me smile and feel good about myself.

Yeah, i feel sorry myself about once every two weeks. Other times I am too busy with other stuff to work about it. I only did it today cause my birthday was a couple days ago. Then today I helped one of my friends with her research stuff. After I did that, she left without saying bye or anything. We were studying in the library, I went downstairs to do some quiet reading. I came back and she is gone. No notes or text messages. Just went poof.. so yeah I wasn't too happy.
 
  • #46
Well I am asian. I don't like hang out with other asians cause the asians don't get along too well. We are too competitive with each other.

You would think that asians should hang out together right.. well one of the things I was taught was that asians are worse than the europeans. Asians backstab and they do it hard and cold. (I experienced a couple of backstabs) So I avoid asians generally. Oh, and I hate those chatty asians girls that never shut up. Annoying me so much.
 
  • #47
johndude222 said:
Not by choice but I am quite poor and can't afford school residence. So I am force to live in some cheap place with poor heating and rather far from campus.

You're perfectly set up to construct a total babe lair. “There's no furniture… so we'll have to sit on the bed. And sorry it's chilly, baby, but we can press our bodies together for warmth.”

Have you seen http://www.imdb.com/media/rm4118060288/tt0396269" ? It's like a documentary for doing this. Especially the part about cruising for women at funerals.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #48
Yeah seen it. Except it isn't real and those guys look pretty good. They didn't need to take much effort to get women to fall for them.. and what's with that girl- the crazy one.. man I don't think people like that exist. She is way to dependent.
 
  • #49
CaptainQuasar said:
I understand Poop-loops and it was a good idea to bring up some of the clinical symptoms of depression. I think what confused the rest of us is that you started posing questions instead of just saying, “by the way, here's a list of symptoms of clinical depression.”


Sorry if I made you all think I am diagnosing him. I'm not that delusional.

And those aren't symptoms for depression, those are symptoms for something called Schizoid Personality Disorder.

This is something I have realized that I have, so I've done some research into it. The way he described himself, it sounded a lot like me, so I figured I'd ask him about it.

If you want to know more, you can wikipedia it, but it's not exactly a disease or something that will kill you. It's more of a personality style.

Anyway, go see a counselor or a psychiatrist. I'd skip the GP if at all possible, because they'll likely just give you some pills and hope you don't bother them anymore or just refer you to a psychiatrist anyway.
 
  • #50
Oh, I'm just kidding johndude. You don't want to really crash funerals looking for women. And women do appreciate a man with HVAC and furniture.

I would say, look for people who are so completely messed up that they don't notice you're Asian. Make a solid core of friends in the fringes and then branch out.
 
  • #51
What's GP. yeah I looked up Schizoid Personality Disorder too a while back.I don't think I am like that cause I do like hang out with people.

I am only secluded because I don't fit in you know. Nerdy asian kid with glasses, hard to fit in with those big jocks and their girlfriends.

A while back I seriously thought of hitting up girls for sex or something like everyone else I known. Then i realized it is kinda weird for a nerdy asian kid to do it. Besides, that isn't me. I like sex as much as every other guy on Earth but seeing girls as sex objects is kinda wrong.

Yeah i am pretty screwed up.
 
  • #52
Counseling will help. Just having someone to talk to about all these issues takes a huge load off your shoulders.

Moreover, you don't have to be a jock to have a girlfriend. Most (straight) guys have a girlfriend at one point or another. 2 of my fellow physics major friends have girlfriends. You just need to be confident.

Here, read over this:

http://www.heartless-*****es.com/rants/niceguys/ng.shtml

EDIT: Okay, so the link is filtered. Instead of the *'s, put in the "B-word". For those who are suddenly apprehensive, don't worry, the site is nothing bad or degrading to women. It's run BY women who are tired of being stereotyped. That particular page opened up my eyes to how I was.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #53
GP is General Practitioner, a type of medical doctor. I think they're also known as Family Physicians, or Primary Care Physicians.
 
  • #54
Poop-Loops said:
Okay, so the link is filtered. Instead of the *'s, put in the "B-word".

Yay vBulletin. Thanks for protecting us from ourselves.
 
  • #55
You can have some of my "wanabe" friends, I have the opposite problem I love to be alone but I have lots of people wanting to get close to me.
 
  • #56
Johndude. Right now you're lower on the social food-chain than plankton. If you want to climb your way to the top you got to grow some fangs and use them every once in a while.

Stop wanting to get people to like you by being nicer to them than they are to you. This is what we call a doormat. These people aren't your friends, and next time they have an assignment they need help with, what you do is you smile at them, politely ask them to ____ your ____ (you can be creative here), and walk away.

I'm not saying be an a-hole; I'm saying don't be afraid to have someone think you are one. Because right now you strike me as the kind of guy who talks in a constantly apologetic tone, as if you have to ask permission just to breathe same air as everyone else in the room.

Being ugly (if you are) has nothing to do with not getting girls.

Being a nice guy means respecting other people and helping them out when they truly need it. That's good.

Being a doormat means giving people respect they don't give you, and doing work for them that they are too lazy to do themselves.

If someone asks you to do something for them that you think is unreasonable, just say "no." Don't sound like you're apologizing. Look at them straight in the eye and say "no." They might think you're an a-hole. So? There's nothing wrong with offending people. Stop trying to please everyone.

Right now don't even worry about getting people to like you or making friends; worry about getting people to respect you, because it sounds like you've lost all respect. Once you have your classmates' respect, then you can worry about which ones you consider your friends.
 
  • #57
PROTIP: One way to get respect is to act as if you already have it.

No, that doesn't mean go around being cocky, it just means carry yourself like you are worth something.
 
  • #58
I just carry around a leather glove to smack people with and challenge them to duels.
 
  • #59
Man, I just learned what a door mat is. Never heard of that term before. I didn't known been nice could be bad. Kk, I need to start learning how to say no. One last thing, you guys sure being door mat is 100% bad? Just need one last confirmation.
 
  • #60
johndude222 said:
One last thing, you guys sure being door mat is 100% bad? Just need one last confirmation.

Not 100% bad. Here's a nifty maxim concerning this, supposedly of http://books.google.com/books?id=hm...s=VicaeKJHGh&sig=hVCQXch7aRYYwcDTk0s1ISXR-MQ":
“For all your days prepare,
And meet them ever alike:
When you are the anvil, bear.
When you are the hammer, strike.”
You must cultivate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitas" , the art of doing the right thing at the right time in the right manner, like the Zen archer does.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
1K
  • · Replies 42 ·
2
Replies
42
Views
3K
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • · Replies 63 ·
3
Replies
63
Views
4K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
924
  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
6K