My textbook is deriving wave speed on a string under tension

19 replies · 3K views · last reply
annamal
Messages
393
Reaction score
33
My textbook is deriving wave speed on a string under tension with confusing thetas. It assumes ##\tan \theta_1 = \frac{-F_1}{F_T}## and ##\tan \theta_2 = \frac{F_2}{F_T}## which confuses me. I know for sure theta is the angle due to the position of y and x, ##\tan \theta = \frac{y}{x}##, but I am confused how you can assume that theta is the angle between the forces. Attached is an image of a graph of the y position vs x position of a wave.
Diagram of a transverse wave segment on a string between x1 and x2, showing tension forces FT at each end and vertical forces F1 and F2, with angles θ1 and θ2 at the points y1 and y2 and the horizontal distance Δx marked.
 
annamal said:
My textbook is deriving wave speed on a string under tension with confusing thetas. It assumes ##\tan \theta_1 = \frac{-F_1}{F_T}## and ##\tan \theta_2 = \frac{F_2}{F_T}## which confuses me. I know for sure theta is the angle due to the position of y and x, ##\tan \theta = \frac{y}{x}##, but I am confused how you can assume that theta is the angle between the forces. Attached is an image of a graph of the y position vs x position of a wave.
View attachment 299804
Consider point 2. Draw in the force ##F## exerted on the small segment of string. What are the x and y components of that force in terms of ##F## and ##\theta_2##?
 
vela said:
Consider point 2. Draw in the force ##F## exerted on the small segment of string. What are the x and y components of that force in terms of ##F## and ##\theta_2##?
That's not answering my question of how come ##\theta_2## and ##\theta_1## are the angles between the forces. ##\theta_2## could be greater or smaller. ##\theta_2## is the angle due to the y and x quantities but not necessarily the angle for the Fx and Fy quantities.
 
OK, let's try a different tack.

Why do you think ##\tan \theta = \frac yx##? I don't see where you're getting that idea from the diagram you provided.

Also, what you do mean by ##\theta## being the angle between the forces? The angle between the components shown is 90 degrees.
 
vela said:
OK, let's try a different tack.

Why do you think ##\tan \theta = \frac yx##? I don't see where you're getting that idea from the diagram you provided.

Also, what you do mean by ##\theta## being the angle between the forces? The angle between the components shown is 90 degrees.
Diagram of a wave pulse on a string with tension F_T pulling left and right at two points, x1 and x2 separated by Δx, with vertical forces F1 and F2, angles θ1 and θ2 marked, and an added point labeled (x3, y3) on the curve.

In the image attached, I added a point (x3, y3). ##\tan(\theta_2) = \frac{y3 - y2}{x3 - x2}## which has nothing to do with the forces. The forces may have a different ##\theta## where ##\tan(\theta) = \frac{Fy}{Fx}##
 
Which way do you think the force the righthand portion of the string exerts on the segment points? (That's why I asked you to draw in that force.) Do you think the situation I drew in the picture is possible?

Diagram of a curve with a red arrow at a point on it tangent to the curve, pointing up and to the right; two dashed vertical lines mark horizontal positions on the curve, labelled Δx below.
 
vela said:
Which way do you think the force the righthand portion of the string exerts on the segment points? (That's why I asked you to draw in that force.) Do you think the situation I drew in the picture is possible?

View attachment 299851
No, I know that. You're not understanding my question. I attached another image. The blue arrow is one possibility of a resultant force vector in which ##\tan(\theta_2) = \frac{Fy}{Fx}##. The orange arrow is another possibility of a resultant force vectors in which ##\tan(\theta_3) = \frac{Fy}{Fx}##. ##\theta_2 != \theta_3##
Diagram of a string segment on a curved wave with tension FT at two points, vertical forces F1 and F2, angles θ1 and θ2, positions x1, x2, x3, y1, y2, and Δx marked, a blue arrow and an orange arrow at the upper point.
 
You're right. I don't understand what you're asking. What do you mean by ##F_x## and ##F_y##? It's apparently not what I think you mean.
 
vela said:
You're right. I don't understand what you're asking. What do you mean by ##F_x## and ##F_y##? It's apparently not what I think you mean.
##F_x = F_T## and ##F_y = F_2##
 
I have no idea why you think that.
 
annamal said:
No, I know that. You're not understanding my question. I attached another image. The blue arrow is one possibility of a resultant force vector in which ##\tan(\theta_2) = \frac{Fy}{Fx}##. The orange arrow is another possibility of a resultant force vectors in which ##\tan(\theta_3) = \frac{Fy}{Fx}##. ##\theta_2 != \theta_3##
View attachment 299857
The force on each point on the string can only come from adjacent parts of the string. Therefore, the force is always parallel to the string at each point. There is only one possibility for the angle, which is the angle the string itself makes.
 
DrClaude said:
The force on each point on the string can only come from adjacent parts of the string. Therefore, the force is always parallel to the string at each point. There is only one possibility for the angle, which is the angle the string itself makes.
Can you explain what you mean by adjacent parts?
 
annamal said:
Can you explain what you mean by adjacent parts?
Imagine the string as a large number of finite segments. The force on each segment is applied by the two adjacent segments, one on either side.

The continuous solution comes from taking the limit as the segment size tends to zero.
 
annamal said:
That's not answering my question of how come θ2 and θ1 are the angles between the forces.
Quite arbitrarily (but obviously the best choice) the tension force has been resolved into a lateral and longitudinal force. This sort of approach is the way we solve hundreds of problems but is probably only valid for small displacements and the diagram exaggerates the scale so that the vectors can be drawn on a diagram.

Sorry for starting at the bottom of this problem but it can often be worth while stating all the basics first.
 
As I was composing another reply, I think I figured out what your question was. Say you have a mass suspended by a string and you pull on the string to accelerate the mass to the right. I think you're envisioning a force on the mass like this:
Free-body diagram of a box labelled m with an orange string running up and to the right, labelled string, and a red arrow labelled F pointing up and to the right from the box, off the line of the string.

where the force exerted by the string doesn't necessarily point in the same direction as the string.

In the typical model of a string, this won't happen. If the string were able to pull on the mass like that, Newton's third law says the mass would pull on the string with an equal and opposite force. The reaction force would causing the tilt of the string to increase, i.e. the string will rotate, until the force is collinear with the string. The assumption is that the string will respond so quickly that the force always along the direction of the string.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: sophiecentaur
PeroK said:
Imagine the string as a large number of finite segments. The force on each segment is applied by the two adjacent segments, one on either side.

The continuous solution comes from taking the limit as the segment size tends to zero.
What do you mean by adjacent segments? The x and y components to the net force?
 
annamal said:
What do you mean by adjacent segments? The x and y components to the net force?
No, a segment is part of the string. The diagram in your original post shows the segment between ##x_1## and ##x_2##.

Adjacent means adjoining or next to.

The string segments exert forces on each other, like links in a chain.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Ibix
Consider a series of beads of mass ##m## connected by massless rigid rods. With ##N=2## beads, it would look like
Diagram of two beads of mass m, labelled A and B, on a stretched string between two fixed walls, with tension T in each segment, angles theta A and theta B, heights y A and y B, and horizontal spacings l.

You can consider a string as the limit of this model when ##N\rightarrow\infty## and ##l\rightarrow0##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and PeroK