B Nalini Joshi's Time Travel Ideas

Click For Summary
Time travel, particularly through closed timelike curves (CTCs), is theoretically possible but lacks practical methods for realization. The discussion emphasizes that while CTCs are not impossible, the absence of a realistic framework for their creation limits meaningful dialogue. Serious scientific literature exists on the topic, but the referenced video does not meet the forum's standards for discussion. Participants are encouraged to explore credible scientific articles and initiate new threads based on those findings. Overall, the conversation highlights the need for a grounded approach to the concept of time travel in physics.
Tomwh98
Gold Member
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Hi everyone I'm a mild physics enthusiast but I wonder if people thought time travel was technically possible? And if Nalini's thoughts were sound on a scientific basis.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
That video isn't a valid basis for discussion. Closed timelike curves (CTC) (which would essentially allow a particle to return to a point in its past light cone) are not impossible. But, a lot of things aren't impossible, theoretically. So, until you have a realistic idea of how you might create a CTC, there's not much basis for discussion.

That said, there are some serious scientific articles on CTC's.
 
  • Like
Likes Lord Jestocost
@PeroK is right, both that this video is not a good source under the forum rules and that there is more serious scientific discussion of CTCs. This thread is closed, but new threads based on those discussions (Googling for “closed timelike curves and the references in the Wikipedia article could be a good start) are welcome.
 
  • Like
Likes Lord Jestocost, PeroK and Vanadium 50
Hello, everyone, hope someone will resolve my doubts. I have posted here some two years ago asking for an explanation of the Lorentz transforms derivation found in the Einstein 1905 paper. The answer I got seemed quite satisfactory. Two years after I revisit this derivation and this is what I see. In the Einstein original paper, the Lorentz transforms derivation included as a premise that light is always propagated along the direction perpendicular to the line of motion when viewed from the...