Gokul43201
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 7,207
- 25
How can you even compare the two? One is clearly a slip of the tongue. How is the other?Vanadium 50 said:And I am awestruck by the fact that the Dem. Presidential candidate didn't know how many states there were.
The only difference is that one of those statements is true.
We all make slips of the tongue, no matter how smart we are. Doggone few of us could be expected to be in front of a camera 6 to 8 hours a day for months and never make one. When we say that we know Sen. Obama is a smart guy, so it must just have been a slip-up, but we know Gov. Palin is an idiot and that this is evidence for this, we are merely reinforcing our prejudices.
The same behavior we are vocally critical of when it comes from the Right.
Besides, your argument makes the faulty assumption that the judgment of the person's intellect is based entirely upon a single quote.
One doesn't need to have a quote from Palin calling Africa a country or South Africa a non-country to make a reasonable judgment of her intellect - there's plenty enough other examples from her interviews.