Photons in the stationary wave?

  • Thread starter bernhard.rothenstein
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Photons Wave
In summary, in the transition from propagating waves to a stationary one, an observer composes two electromagnetic waves of the same frequency propagating in opposite directions. This creates a stationary wave, with the photons or electrons being a superposition of the two opposite waves. When viewed from a moving frame, the character of the wave changes due to the Doppler frequency shift. However, the number of photons or electrons remains conserved between the rest and moving frames. The nodes of the standing wave form a stationary ruler and oscillations provide a set of stationary clocks, with the observer at rest being able to construct a moving node ruler and oscillation clocks using two oppositely moving waves. This allows for the building of stationary and moving space-time grids
  • #1
Consider that an observer composes two electromagnetic waves of the same frequency propagating in opposite directions in order to obtain a stationary wave. Please tell me a short story about the behaviour of the photons in the transition from propagating waves to a stationary one.
What does detect an observer moving relative to me and watching the experiment I just perform. Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
In QFT, photons are quanta of the EM potential field, just as electrons are quanta of the electron field. In either case, the quanta of a standing wave can be written in terms of quanta of traveling waves in opposite directions.
The photon or electron would be such a superposition. Going to a moving frame, the Doppler frequency shift would be different for each component, so the character of the wave will change. It is a homework exercise to calculate the change. The answer for photons, will be the same as for classical EM plane waves.
 
  • #3
stationary wave

Meir Achuz said:
In QFT, photons are quanta of the EM potential field, just as electrons are quanta of the electron field. In either case, the quanta of a standing wave can be written in terms of quanta of traveling waves in opposite directions.
The photon or electron would be such a superposition. Going to a moving frame, the Doppler frequency shift would be different for each component, so the character of the wave will change. It is a homework exercise to calculate the change. The answer for photons, will be the same as for classical EM plane waves.

Thank you. That is the way in which I am looking for help on the Forum. We did the homework exercise in order to show the conservation of the number of counted photons.
 
  • #4
A simple sum of two EM waves with equal but opposite wavenumbers k and -k (kc=frequency) can represent a photon that is moving in either the + or -x direction. The photon is moving at c but its probability current is zero. From a moving frame the two opposite k's will not be the same because of their doppler shifts, but the photon will still be moving at c in either the + or -x' direction. The probability current is flowing at v. It is clear that there is still only one photon. As more photons are added to the state the number is likewise conserved between the rest and moving frames.

The nodes of the standing wave form a stationary ruler and the oscillations of the amplitude between nodes provide a set of stationary clocks. When viewed from a moving frame, the doppler shifts of the two component waves make the moving nodes appear closer together by the Lorentz contraction and the oscillations become slower by the relativistic time dilation. The observer at rest can construct a moving node ruler and moving oscillation clocks by using two oppositely moving waves of different frequency. Stationary and moving space-time grids can be built in this way with light waves.
 
  • #5
special relativity in the stationary wave

country boy said:
A simple sum of two EM waves with equal but opposite wavenumbers k and -k (kc=frequency) can represent a photon that is moving in either the + or -x direction. The photon is moving at c but its probability current is zero. From a moving frame the two opposite k's will not be the same because of their doppler shifts, but the photon will still be moving at c in either the + or -x' direction. The probability current is flowing at v. It is clear that there is still only one photon. As more photons are added to the state the number is likewise conserved between the rest and moving frames.

The nodes of the standing wave form a stationary ruler and the oscillations of the amplitude between nodes provide a set of stationary clocks. When viewed from a moving frame, the doppler shifts of the two component waves make the moving nodes appear closer together by the Lorentz contraction and the oscillations become slower by the relativistic time dilation. The observer at rest can construct a moving node ruler and moving oscillation clocks by using two oppositely moving waves of different frequency. Stationary and moving space-time grids can be built in this way with light waves.

Thanks for the interesting idea you offer.
So far as I know relativists make a net distinction between observers equipped with rods and synchronized clocks located at differfent points in space confronted with effects like time dilation and length contraction, and observers located at a given point in space collecting information about events taking place at different points in space form the light that arrives at the point where they are located confronted with effects like Doppler or aberration.
Do you consider that the observer you propose is an uptodated first kind of observer?
I have to think if the lengths involved transform by contraction or by Doppler effect?
Kind regards:rofl:
 
  • #6
The two observers in my example, moving and at rest, each collect information from measurements at various locations in their respective frames. The measurements at each location are made by observers or recording/transmitting devices. Since the central observer who collects the information from distant points can compile it over a period of time, his results are not affected by times-of-flight from the distant points. He is probably not like the second type of observer you describe above. Instead, the many observers or devices at distributed locations are like your first type of observer.
 

1. What is a stationary wave?

A stationary wave is a type of wave that appears to be standing still, even though energy is still being transferred through the medium. This occurs when two waves with the same frequency and amplitude travel in opposite directions and interfere with each other, creating points of constructive and destructive interference.

2. What are photons?

Photons are particles of light that act as both a wave and a particle. They have no mass and travel at the speed of light. They carry energy and are responsible for electromagnetic interactions.

3. How do photons relate to stationary waves?

In a stationary wave, photons are trapped in a specific region due to the interference of two waves. This creates areas of high and low energy, called nodes and antinodes, respectively. The photons continue to oscillate between these points, contributing to the overall appearance of the stationary wave.

4. What is the significance of stationary waves in the study of light?

Stationary waves play a crucial role in understanding the behavior of light. They help explain concepts such as interference, diffraction, and polarization. Additionally, the study of stationary waves has led to the discovery of new technologies, such as lasers and fiber optics.

5. Can stationary waves exist in all types of mediums?

Yes, stationary waves can exist in any medium where waves can propagate, such as air, water, or even solid materials. They are not limited to just light waves, but can also occur with sound waves, water waves, and more.

Suggested for: Photons in the stationary wave?

Replies
19
Views
911
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
926
Replies
41
Views
3K
Back
Top