Please clear my electromagnetism doubt about units

  • #1
It is a well known fact that, in electromagnetic units, strength of a shell and strength of current flowing through its boundary are same. See here.

\begin{equation}
\begin{matrix}
\text{i.e.}\: i \text{(biot)} = \phi \text{(biot) }
\end{matrix}
\tag{1}
\end{equation}

(a) While converting to SI:

\begin{equation}
\begin{matrix}
i\: \text{biot} = i\: (10 \text{Amp}) = 10i\: \text{Amp} = I \text{Amp}\\
\text{where biot} = 10 \text{Amp and}\: 10i = I
\tag{a}
\end{matrix}
\end{equation}
Also:
\begin{equation}
\begin{matrix}
\phi\: \text{biot} = \phi\: (10 \text{Amp}) = 10\phi\: \text{Amp} = \Phi \text{Amp}\\
\text{where biot} = 10 \text{Amp and}\: 10\phi = \Phi
\tag{b}
\end{matrix}
\end{equation}

Therefore in SI (by comparing with equation (1)):

##I## (Amp) = ##\Phi## (Amp)

(b) While converting to electrodynamic units:
\begin{equation}
\begin{matrix}
i\: \text{biot} = i\: (\sqrt{2}\: \text{ed}) = \sqrt{2}i\: \text{ed} = j\: \text{ed}\\
\text{where biot} = \sqrt{2}\: \text{ed and}\: \sqrt{2}\: i = j
\tag{c}
\end{matrix}
\end{equation}
Also:
\begin{equation}
\begin{matrix}
\phi\: \text{biot} = \phi\: (\sqrt{2}\: \text{ed}) = \sqrt{2}\phi\: \text{ed} = \Phi_j\: \text{ed}\\
\text{where biot} = \sqrt{2}\: \text{ed and}\: \sqrt{2}\: \phi = \Phi_j
\tag{d}
\end{matrix}
\end{equation}

Therefore in electrodynamic (by comparing with equation (1)):

##j## (ed) = ##\Phi_j## (ed)

(c) While converting to electrostatic units:

\begin{equation}
\begin{matrix}
i\: \text{biot} = i\: (3\times10^{10}\: \text{StatAmp}) = 3\times10^{10}i\: \text{StatAmp} = k\: \text{StatAmp}\\
\text{where biot} = 3\times10^{10}\: \text{StatAmp and}\: 3\times10^{10}\: i = k
\tag{e}
\end{matrix}
\end{equation}

\begin{equation}
\begin{matrix}
\phi\: \text{biot} = \phi\: (3\times10^{10}\: \text{StatAmp}) = 3\times10^{10}\phi\: \text{StatAmp} = \Phi_k\: \text{StatAmp}\\
\text{where biot} = 3\times10^{10}\: \text{StatAmp and}\: 3\times10^{10}\: \phi = \Phi_k
\tag{f}
\end{matrix}
\end{equation}

Therefore in electrostatic units (by comparing with equation (1)):

##k## (StatAmp) = ##\Phi_k## (StatAmp)

i.e. in all units, strength of the shell and strength of current flowing through its boundary are same.

Question 1: Am I correct?

if yes

Question 2: Then why is it said that "strength of the shell and strength of current flowing through its boundary are same only in certain units like electromagnetic units"?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2020 Award
31,824
8,686
Well, 1 biot is not really equal to 10 A. They are equivalent in some equations but not in other equations. The issue is that Maxwell's equations and the other equations of electromagnetism are different when written in different units. So the straight substitution that you are trying to do is not correct.

1 biot^2 equals 1 dyne in emu, but 1 A^2 does not equal 1 N in SI
 

Related Threads on Please clear my electromagnetism doubt about units

  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
694
  • Last Post
2
Replies
31
Views
30K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
8K
Top