Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around recommendations for textbooks on classical mechanics, focusing on the balance between introductory material and more advanced topics such as Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formulations. Participants express their preferences and experiences with various texts, considering factors like mathematical rigor and problem sets.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Technical explanation
- Exploratory
Main Points Raised
- One participant seeks textbooks that cover both basic and advanced topics in classical mechanics without jumping to unrelated subjects like special relativity or thermodynamics.
- Goldstein's textbook is mentioned multiple times, with some participants questioning its suitability for beginners.
- Marion and Thornton are recommended for those without prior classical mechanics courses, while Symon is also suggested as a good choice.
- Some participants express a preference for books that do not require extensive mathematical background, citing Griffith over r.Shankar in quantum mechanics as an example.
- Several other titles are proposed, including Taylor, Kibble Berkshire, Morin, Scheck, and Gregory, indicating a variety of options available.
- Concerns are raised about the quality of newer editions of textbooks, particularly Marion, with some participants expressing a preference for older editions due to perceived changes in content and presentation.
- One participant mentions Landau/Lifshitz as a strong option for those with a solid math background, suggesting it could be beneficial for the original poster.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on a single recommended textbook, as multiple competing views and preferences are expressed regarding the suitability of various texts for different backgrounds and needs.
Contextual Notes
Some participants note the limitations of newer editions of textbooks, mentioning issues such as changes in style, unnecessary additions, and high prices, which may affect their recommendations.