Post Editing: Why Was My Thread Moved?

  • Thread starter Thread starter W3pcq
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
A user expressed confusion over their thread being moved to an older discussion, questioning whether it was a mistake or a standard practice. They noted difficulties with the search function, which may have contributed to their inability to find the existing thread before posting. The user requested deletion of their posts, feeling that their contributions were taken out of context and made them appear uninformed. Mentors acknowledged the request and indicated they would discuss it further. The conversation highlights issues with thread management and search functionality on the forum.
W3pcq
Messages
109
Reaction score
0
what's up with moving my thread in skepticism and debunking to the end of a newer created thread on the exact same topic? Was this a mistake, or is there a reason. Usually you move a thread to a new category.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Have you got a link to the thread?
 
Never mind, I thought it was a newer thread, it's actually a thread from 06. I feel like an idiot, sorry for the waste of time. I guess it has already been debunked.
 
LOL! Nevermind.
 
I actually even did a search before posting, but nothing came up. I guess locked threads are filtered out. Was the thread from 06 locked and reopened with the addition of the posts in my thread? Why does it need to be locked anyways?
 
W3pcq said:
I actually even did a search before posting, but nothing came up. I guess locked threads are filtered out. Was the thread from 06 locked and reopened with the addition of the posts in my thread? Why does it need to be locked anyways?

The search function doesn't always work very well here. I assume that by your surprise, you didn't receive any warning or infraction for the post in question, which is probably because the related post was old enough that missing it in a search was a reasonable error. Google seems to be updating its index of our site almost instantly lately, so you can sometimes have better luck searching for old threads in google by specifying us as the site.
 
Last edited:
thanx
 
Actually, I would appreciate it if I could have my posts https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=123863&page=3 here deleted since adding them to the end of another thread puts my posts out of context and makes me look stupid. It is as if I read all the previous posts, which don't even come up in searches, and then responded when in reality I started a thread which was moved to the end of a new one.
 
W3pcq said:
Actually, I would appreciate it if I could have my posts https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=123863&page=3 here deleted since adding them to the end of another thread puts my posts out of context and makes me look stupid. It is as if I read all the previous posts, which don't even come up in searches, and then responded when in reality I started a thread which was moved to the end of a new one.

The mentors are considering/discussing your request. We'll get back to you on this.
 
Back
Top