Posting images expansion to other forums

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mk
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the desire to expand the ability to post images beyond the General Discussion (GD) forum to other sections like Other Sciences and Physics. Concerns about bandwidth, moderation, and potential distractions from excessive image use are raised, with examples of other forums suffering from clutter due to image overload. While some participants advocate for attachments as a more organized solution, others express frustration with the approval process. The reliability of linked images is also questioned, as they can become unavailable if the original source is removed. Overall, the conversation highlights a tension between the desire for visual content and the need for a clean, manageable forum environment.
Mk
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4
The posting images ability is only available in GD as we all know, why can't we have this expanded to say... Other Sciences, and/or Physics? Bandwidth issues or something? Oh c'mon you must make a ton of money off this site! PLEEEEAASEE! :smile: I know the right guys in the red light district.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Bandwidth, hotlink and moderation concerns. What is wrong with attaching images?
 
I must admit that I have seen other forums where the pics had gotten way out of hand. As an example, my wife goes on to a board where EVERY poster hot links to banners that do countdowns and have 4 or 5 pictures in their sigs, etc...There is so much crap on there you can't tell where the posts begin and end.

Attachments are really the way to go. It does kind of stink to wait for the approval process, but I consider that our little blow to the instant gratification idea.
 
Well, i would like to see possibility in the tutorial secton for improved clarity but uploading is only slightly inconvinient.
 
Mattara said:
Well, i would like to see possibility in the tutorial secton for improved clarity but uploading is only slightly inconvinient.[/QUOTE]
Nah, I don't think it's a good idea. It will be a great distraction. One can attach an image in a tutorial, or can provide an external link. It will look much better, and neater.
 
FredGarvin said:
I must admit that I have seen other forums where the pics had gotten way out of hand. As an example, my wife goes on to a board where EVERY poster hot links to banners that do countdowns and have 4 or 5 pictures in their sigs, etc...There is so much crap on there you can't tell where the posts begin and end.

Attachments are really the way to go. It does kind of stink to wait for the approval process, but I consider that our little blow to the instant gratification idea.
Of course, if you're really impatient, you can PM a mentor to let them know your attachment is there and waiting approval.

Another problem with img tags is they are dependent on the original source remaining available. If you link to an image that's there today, and the site takes it down tomorrow, it's gone the way of the big red X in the sky. This is why it definitely wouldn't be a good idea for tutorials.
 
Moonbear said:
Another problem with img tags is they are dependent on the original source remaining available. If you link to an image that's there today, and the site takes it down tomorrow, it's gone the way of the big red X in the sky. This is why it definitely wouldn't be a good idea for tutorials.

Well, if you get a good host or mount it yourself it would work
 
How odd...Does anyone else see the " code is on" in the science tutorial section?
 
Back
Top